Using the ‘T’ form is becoming more and more acceptable across certain
countries. In others, however, the T form is considered unacceptable. Nowadays,
some critics believe that using the T form is actually causing more social
divide than using the V form. Some have even gone as far to describe the T form
as a “form of violence”.
Although opinion is divided, there are many sub-categories which should
be considered. In online social media, for example, using the T form has
various uses. The ‘handier’ reason being that ‘tú’, ‘tu’ etc. takes up less
characters, and is, as a result, less time-consuming. As a result, many believe
that an egalitarian political discourse has been established, which is an
important, as the platform allows for an element of freedom of speech. Countries
such as Russia, however, consider an informal online tone as completely
unacceptable, and Japan has even gone as far as to evolve its own formal online
lingo. At the other end of the spectrum, Italy was using a T form way before
the Net’s interference.
With family and friends, the T form seems like an obvious choice, showing
intimacy and familiarity. In France, it is apparently more ‘normal’ to refer to
grandma as ‘vous’, which stereotypically, may suggest a direct correlation with
those more likely to use Twitter and other social media platforms. One may
argue that the older generations are “stuck in their ways”. This is something
that we would traditionally relate to a public relations setting, whereby the V
form is used to show respect – as we are taught at secondary school. This,
however, may not be the case, as those who are of the same ilk also seem to
create an alliance, which many consider to be going against the desired changes
that came about in France, for example, as a result of the social upheavals of Mai
1968. This, though, seems exclusive to the inner-dealings of these groups, and
for you and I to ‘tutoyer’ them would be a mistake.
The idea of ‘showing respect’ via the V form is something of an outdated
practice, it may seem. In certain settings, though, it would be useless. Many
see the T form as insulting, suggesting that we would only require it when we
want to show our anger towards someone, or to address someone in a
condescending manner. An argument after a car accident may be a good example of
this, whereas in English, we may just shout “learn to fucking drive”. No T nor
V needed.
The most common ‘V occasion’ which still exists in today’s society, I
would say, is that of client / server relationships. It would be uncommon to
hear a T form when being served in a restaurant or greeted at a hotel, and this
is arguably a muted form of gratitude. This is something that also has a
presence in the world of social media. A rare occasion when there is some form
of accord between the real world and cyberspace.
Tags: tu, vous, tv form, greetings, address, formality, speech, french