When I first arrived in China in 2008 I found a nation in the grips of a
mania. There was an obsession with western TV shows, Hollywood movies, and
above all, learning English.
In those early days it wasn’t uncommon for
strangers to walk up to me and say: “Hello. I speak English. Let’s be friends.”
It was jarring (and a little creepy). China was in the mist of being
westernized, there was no doubt about it, I could see it everywhere. Basketball
was the national sport. Premiership football was all over the TV. When I was
invited to dinner Chinese friends took me to Pizza Hut so they could impress me
with their knife and fork skills.
When I moved back home, a little over 10 years
later, China had become a different place. The west had lost its appeal.
Curiosity in all things western had waned. Even foreign TV shows held little
interest for a China more preoccupied with embracing its own culture again.
While journalists and experts are quick to blame
government’s patriotic policies for this change, I believe this is only part of
the story. To me, the Chinese people have grown confident of the country’s
accomplishments on the world’s stage. They have also grown weary of western countries
attitude towards their homeland, believing it to be unfair and downright
hypocritical. In short, the Chinese believe the time has come to promote and
elevate their own culture and their own ways of doing things.
Being a teacher back in 2008 was a fascinating
time. I could easily fill a two hour class with nothing more than allowing
students to ask me questions. They had a curiosity about me and my hometown
that I had never experienced before. At first I thought it was a time wasting
technique, but their excited tone told me otherwise. They asked many questions,
from how much money to do make, to do foreigners get headaches?
On occasion I got to turn the tide and ask some
questions myself. I always asked why they were learning English.
Answers fell into three categories: to travel abroad, to study abroad, to work
in an international company (and possibly go abroad.) It wasn’t difficult to
spot the common tread in these responses. To them English wasn’t a hobby, it
was a key to a door they had never been behind, it was a pathway to a better or
more interesting future.
At the that time many of the students didn’t have
passports. Instead, they viewed the world through the window of the internet
and American and western tv shows. Friends. Sex and the City. These shows
depicted lifestyles completely alien to the common Chinese person. Not just in
a physical way, but in a psychological way too. These shows had characters with strong
individualistic tendencies; they did their own thing and rarely conformed. For
the students I taught this was radial and attractive. The adults I taught
worked sixty-hour weeks and teenagers I taught were up each night to 1am doing
homework. And none of this was by choice. It was forced upon them by bosses, parents,
and society itself. Learning English just might be a ticket to a better way of
living.
Of course, I wasn’t the only one noticing this growing obsession with
English and western ideas. The government were paying close attention too. They
had previously stamped out a infestation of western thinking back in 1989 but
the memory still loomed large. While the Chinese government always maintained
it was dedicated to providing better options for its people - better job
options, better healthcare options, better housing options - it drew the line
at offering ideology options. There was only one way of thinking: the communist
party way.
At the time the party still had absolute control
on society. Their power was felt in all corners of life, from the education to
business. You couldn’t go for a walk without passing government slogans on a
wall or browse the web without the great firewall telling you the site was not found. Even at the school where I worked, we felt
the ever-watchful eye of the government. On the first day all teachers were
lectured on what topics we couldn’t mention to students. The three Ts were off
limits. Tibet, Taiwan, and Tiananmen. Punishment for mentioning these subject
matters was deportation or possible imprisonment.
But the government’s power worked more like a
deterrent. Their perceived reach was much longer than reality. None of these
policies were policed or enforced. In the foreign community we never heard of
anyone being deported and students were more than happy to talk about these
topics.
But all of that was about to change.
When President Xi came to power in 2012 he
immediately implemented sweeping changes. The economy, the military, schools
and universities were all hit with heavy reform policies. He also introduced an
all encompassing Chinese ideology. In order for this to succeed it was clear
western ideas needed to be expunged. What followed was typical totalitarian
behavior. Overnight books were removed from libraries and stores, TV shows were
taken down from the most popular platforms. It was done with great fanfare.
Party members who were reprimanded for having affairs or taking drugs came forward
to apologize for being corrupted by ideals inadvertently picked up from western
movies. It was ridiculous but it worked and soon trickled down to the masses.
The phrase. 崇洋媚外, which roughly translates to
person crazy about foreign things had always been part of the Chinese
vernacular. I had mostly heard people use it as a joke, however, after 2015 I
noticed that it was being used more and more, especially online. Now it was
used as a harsh insult and directed anyone who spoke favorably about western culture
or products. Around this time also I noticed some push back regarding speaking
English. On a few occasions while outside at speaking events myself and
students were told: This is China. Speak Chinese.
I had hoped these episodes were nothing more than
unfortunate interactions but after discussions with other foreign friends I
could tell this was becoming more frequent. It was nothing we couldn’t handle
but we felt a shift in attitude toward us. Something had changed.
It was hard to know whether this was the result of
the government polices or the result of what was happening in the world. This
all coincided with Western governments taking a hard stance against Beijing and
China was becoming more assertive on the world stage.
I agreed to a certain extent with their woes.
China and its citizens were growing tired of countries that dropped bombs on
poor people talking about human right abuses. It was comical. Furthermore, many
of the students I had taught had got their passports and travel to western countries.
They had been sorely let down. They saw filthy, expensive cities riddled with
crime and they started to consider the idea that the west was not worthy or
praise or admiration.
China has grown a lot over the last 30 years. It
has incorporated some western ideas into its society but has also rejected many
more. This doesn’t always have to be a negative thing. While their political
system can be cruel and totalitarian, it has also lifted hundreds of millions
of people out of poverty and crime is almost non-existent. Could it be time for
western governments to finally start incorporating at little bit of Chinese culture.
Tags: cultural nationalism, humanities