I have, I think, completed a draft of TMA1 but I have to say it's been hard work
Not unenjoyable, I'm pleased to say, but a real brain-knotter. Not sure if it is any good, actually, but at least it's done. Will put it away now and have another look in a week or two.
Tricky to try to critique Locke given (a) difficulty of getting into the language to his meaning, or as near as I can, and (b) difficulty of getting my head around his 'puzzle cases' in Mackie's admirable phrase, and (c) difficulty of having to deal with the ideas as they are there, rather than what I'm bringing to it in terms of preconceptions and prejudices (or commitments, depending on how you see things?)
There seems so much one could write about and in so many directions. I kept starting an idea and then disagreeing with it as I tried to develop it. Is that what philosophers do? God knows how they finish anything in that case, or perhaps it's meant to be an ongoing situation...