Received the result of TMA04 last night and my worst mark so far, 75%. Still a good pass, but a little disappointing. Having now read Gill's comments though I can see where i went wrong and now kicking myself over some of the errors I made, but also acknowledge that there were parts I did get wrong, some of it in the editing I think.
Form PT3e First:
Congratulations on resilience and commitment. Not too much from this section as it is a general overview, comments on the essay and plan to follow below more important. The 'collective memory' part I probably didn't pay enough attention to. I did avoid just telling the history. At the end of this section Gill gives things to do before the reflective TMA05.
On to the Essay:
On the Essay plan, Gill comments that she is glad to see I took her advice from TMA03 and worked on my plan as I worked through the unit. This I found was a big help. Also good to note my sources. Asked if I found it easier to write my first draft after this, I agree it was, but maybe too many words caused me issues, so may review that on my next assignment. Also complimented me on making notes on the guidance.
On to the essay itself. Gill complimented my introduction on focussing on the question, and on my first paragraph, my signposting. The final sentence of my opening paragraph also had issues with how it flowed. I was concerned about this paragraph when writing the assignment and I did read it loud to myself but reading it now I understand exactly what Gill is saying, it is a poorly constructed sentence, and something I need to pay much mor attention to in the future.
Some of my in-text referencing I did get wrong, one of the things I'm a little sore at myself about. In paragraph one I referenced as 'Reading 6.1 in Forbes...., which should have been referenced as 'Hyde, 1892 quoted in Forbes, 2019, pp. 290-292'. This was in part as a tutorial I went on a few weeks before had suggested this as a way to reference readings, so for this essay I did this for the readings. I will learn from this on future assignments. Another issue with the in-text referencing was on quoting from the website, not putting a section number in, so another part to work on this in the future. The other on on the in-text referencing was video referencing putting time from to, 00:00 to 00:00. My reference list though was the correct layout.
My second paragraph was again good signposting, so that I have improved on since TMA03. This paragraph gave me a few issues whilst writing it. I changed it, rewrote it, deleted it, rewrote it again and was never entirely happy with it and it obviously did cost me marks. Gill points out that although I explained that Pearce didn't like trews and preferred a kilt to be the traditional dress, I didn't 'explain why Pearse argued for the kilt', and again with Countess Constance Markievicz I didn explain her political purposes with the 'current suffragette movement'. My link at the end of this was also incorrect as I didn't link it to a distinctive Irish national identity.
My next paragraph was much better with 'good focus' and a 'good use of mini conclusion'.
The next few were good as well, so it was only really the first few that were a problem. Another issue I wished to kick myself on was was a apostrophe on 1920s and 1930s. It is just plural so no apostrophe.
On the conclusion Gill commented 'Great focus on the question'. In summing up Gill acknowledges that I have an understanding of the module material and selected appropriate examples. One big improvement from TMA 03 was was my signposting sentences and mini conclusions at the beginning and end of paragraphs. On the content Gill commented that I could have expanded on 'served political purpose' aspect of the question and as mentioned above the 'shared collective memory'.
So overall a good pass, but down on my previous marks, a lot to work on. Think I need to take more care of the little things and make sure all parts flow and keep checking that I have answered all of the question. Plenty to think about going forward and TMA05 and TMA06. A lot still to improve and get write.
On the wider aspects of the module, I have now completed last weeks and this weeks units and ready for 'Music and Protest in South Africa'. Enjoyed 'Antigone' and 'The Island' very much.