Working mathematically on symbols
Transcript: Working mathematically on symbols
Please note that this transcript only covers Dave Hewitt's voiceover for the video and is not a transcript of the classroom exchanges.
DAVE HEWlTT [00:13]: When I first started teaching, I entered into a school where the diet was mainly text books or workouts and I felt that the way the pupils were being asked to work was getting them to do rather repetitive tasks and to always seek an authority somewhere whether it is me or whether it is the answers at the back of a book. um-I was very unhappy with that and I-and I worked quite hard at-at er-working with them in a different way where I tried to find out what they could do themselves.
[00:50]: They have minds they bring with them, all sorts of experiences and abilities and I spent quite a long time er - many years -in classrooms finding out what er - what they can do, if left in a sense, to their own devices, and I. found that the pupils realised that they can be quite creative within mathematics and that they are functioning mathematicians at their level; and I saw many pupils grow er - as a consequence of that and um quite often I would arrive in a classroom and er - if I happened to be a bit late then quite often they were working already and they they were quite autonomous in that sense.
[01:42]: I then also began to ask the question "Well, what is my role?" and I felt that I wanted to see whether um - I could possibly accelerate this learning so that they might be able to learn faster er -just as comfortably; and as a consequence I think I've begun working in ways where I'm quite controlling what's - what's happening in a classroom - um - I'm very much controlling it - and in many ways the activity relies on -as a controlling body in that room.
[02:24]: I hope, and I feel, that I succeed er - in still making them realise that they - they are still in control. so I'm not er - I'm not telling them what to do but I'm trying to effect their attention and perhaps direct their attention to different things to-so that they can notice things perhaps a little bit quicker than if their attention wasn't drawn to certain things.
[02:54]: These lessons are not every lesson: I - I won't control it in that way every lesson it's quite often just a starter that may last for one, or two, or three lessons at the most I would have thought; but sometimes I feel that they notice that they have gained quite a lot within a lesson and I'm wondering whether, in a sense, that's a little addictive that they actually like what's Mr. Hewitt going to do in the next lesson and er - where is he going to take us now.
[03:25 - 22:20] 'RULERS' (Year 8) First Lessson
[06:14]: I use the idea of a class speaking in unison, in - in a sort of chorus way um - on a number of occasions. on this ' occasion· I wanted to use it because you get carried along with-you get soaked up in what's going on; and I also you contribute because of that. You are committing yourself to saying that next number and there's a selfchecking element in that there were times during that lesson when people said a different number and it can be clearly heard that there are two or three numbers being said. And that means that everyone bas an opportunity to reflect on "Hang on, did I say the right number, er-did I say the wrong number?" and they have to work on that or reflect on that.
[11:14]: It's very natural for children to often come up with a question like "Is this right?" and I try not to play the role of the checker, and "yes" or "no" because I tend to feel that they then feel that er-"I'll do something and I'll find out whether it's right by the teacher." I want them to be in a position where they can know that something is right and feel confident about that, so I try to deflect that question away from-from me if I can whilst still, at the same time, not annoying them and saying "find out for yourself".
[15:12]: At one time I - I introduced the equals sign um-and I didn't actually say anything about it and explain it at that time because at that time we understood that we were talking about the fact that this and that had the same effect. With both of them I started here and ended up there, and so there was in a sense an equivalence between these two. And so since we were talking about equivalents at the time, by me putting the equals sign whilst we were talking, the two get associated and that what we've just said I tend to be right in this way and the implicit meaning of the equals sign gets taken up in that way and it becomes the written language through which we record what we've just said to one another.
[21:47]: One thing I did use was, I asked-I suggested they write it up on the board for others to check. If they're going to go up to the board write it they quite often think "Oh, well hang on before I do that, I better make sure that this is right". And so that forces them back into looking again and doing their own checking and I tend to find that when they come up and write on the board, they're feeling actually quite confident and quite sure about it.
[22:21 - 36:51] 'THINK OF A NUMBER' (Year 9) First Lessson, 5 minutes in
[36:52 - 57:02] 'RULERS' (Year 8) Second Lessson
[37:57]: I'm not a provider of images so much, I'm a provider of an activity where I know they'll be developing images to create their story for what's going on in the activity. And the activity contains implicitly the-the mathematics that I want to work on.
[48:59]: I use noises at times because they are a form of getting attention to a particular thing so I might use a particular noise as I'm going along a dividing line and one, the fact that I'm using a noise means that I'm indicating I want some attention here, er-and also they can provide an image for whatever it is. I mean, in this case, it's an image for that I've put the plus sign "z-z-zip" along the end of that line and the image helps to recall how things are written.
[55:19]: Another way in which I introduce symbols is that because within the 'Rulers' activity, or within the 'Think of a Number' activity the focus is on what we're doing so that in a sense I'm not really ever interested in the answer, I'm interested in how I am getting to an answer; and so with that focus there can come a realisation that it actually doesn't matter with what I started with -what number I might have started with -it actually doesn't matter. I can not put er-a number there, I can put anything there and we can still say what we have to do and so a symbol can be introduced as, well whatever it is we put there, we know what it is we have to do -and an x could be introduced or an alpha could be introduced or-and whatever, because the attention isn't with a number, the attention is in with the process, with the operation.
Working mathematically on symbols is a 58-minute Open University video from 1990-91 showing teacher Dave Hewitt working with his Key Stage 3 (lower secondary) mathematics classes.