Charity or Duty?
[ 2 minute read ]
A while ago I was studying pop-philosophy, which is cherry-picking the bits that interest us and leaving the real stuff to the clever people. If someone asks me name a philosopher I would instantly say Kant but it is pretty ambiguous just to say that. If the person doesn't know me and they are market-researchers for who knows what, they might think I have some kind of irascible problem with them. 'What did you call me?' or they might think I don't know any and cannot think of any, or they might sagely nod and think, 'Ah, here is a pop-philosopher.'
I was intrigued by Immanuel Kant discussing ethics and duty. I think the writer of the book came up with the example of visiting someone in hospital. Do we do that because we care or because we are expected to? The charitable person lying in a bed with only one pillow in hospital might feel lonely without my visit but understands that I dislike formality and being in environments that require strict protocols. I don't feel I have any autonomy in those environments; scary monsters to me.
The reciprocation of gifts is another weird one for me. Did you buy me a gift because you love me; I have more money than you; or because it is that time of year (birthday, anniversary, religious thing)?
'I always buy Martin a small gift because he binds himself to protocol and is totally confused by gifts, so he buys me a much more expensive gift in return. If I want a tractor I give him a pony. If I want a ride-on mower I give him a sheep.'
In truth, I just spray gifts and charity in all directions. No-one likes me more for it. I am a hippopotamus spinning its tail as it defecates to them. 'Why would anyone want a ceramic dog with one of its legs broken off? Who needs that many tomatoes?' Something many of these people don't realise is that I keep a record of their good deeds in a secret book that I hide from the customs and excise people when they burst in every now and again. 'Aha, we have caught you.....typing on an old laptop. Where is your TV?' I don't have one, but that is so unusual these days that they never believe me. I keep frozen milk in the freezer to make them cups of tea to take back out to their 'hidey-holes' in the garden or in their vans outside. It is my duty to be nice; they are only doing their duty. I check my secret book for good deeds towards me and send Christmas cards accordingly. The recipients always feel obligated to send a card back though. No, the thank you in the card is a mark of my humility, and respect that you helped me when I needed it, or you were just kind to me.
You see, if we are to believe we are charitable we have to move from performing duties to becoming founts of generosity. The black-clad and masked men and women lurking outside to catch me doing something I shouldn't be doing are only human, I think. They might like tea every now and again.