OU blog

Personal Blogs

A picture of Russell Larke

The Metric Trap

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Russell Larke, Wednesday 4 November 2026 at 12:41

Goodhart's Law. It states: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure."

The easiest way to understand this is to look at a call centre.

Management decides they need to improve efficiency, so they set a target: all customer service reps must keep their average call time under three minutes. It seems logical. Shorter calls mean more customers served, right?

Mechanically, what happens next is predictable. The reps want to hit the target. So they start rushing people off the phone. They skip the small talk. They ignore complex problems. They hang up the second the transaction is done.

Average call time goes down. The target is met. But the actual goal—resolving customer issues—has been destroyed. The system optimized for the metric, not the objective.

We see this everywhere. A school wants higher test scores, so teachers stop teaching critical thinking and start teaching test-taking tricks. A hospital wants to reduce wait times, so they start classifying minor injuries as major ones to game the statistical average. A trader wants to increase their win rate, so they cut their winners early and hold their losers, resulting in a 90% win rate and a blown-up account.

When you turn a complex, nuanced human process into a single number, people will figure out how to manipulate the number. They aren't being malicious; they are just responding rationally to the incentive structure you built.

The structural lesson is that you cannot manage a system by staring at a dashboard. Metrics are maps, not the territory. If you forget that, you will eventually get exactly what you asked for—and nothing that you actually wanted.

Permalink
Share post