OU blog

Personal Blogs

Week 12 Activity Richardson 2005 article

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Terry O'Sullivan, Tuesday 3 May 2011 at 11:51
As you read the paper, think about the ways in which similar ideas were discussed in previous weeks and refer to the relevant module materials: Oh no! sufficient to the activity is the article thereof!!!sad
  1. Do you think the innovations described in Weeks 8 and 9 as ‘learning design’ would induce more desirable approaches to studying on the part of the students?

Richardson's evidence suggests that student-side factors (conceptions of, approaches to, and perceptions about learning) dictate what happens to a large extent (doh!). Perhaps 'learning design' might be able to exert some influence on some students, but don't expect miracles. According to Beetham (2007) learner-centred design, which one might expect to encourage deep learning, is vulnerable to uncertainties about what variations amongst learners are relevant to what you are trying to do as an educator, and the practicalities of dealing with variance in a way which supports individual learners (p. 31).

Also, who is to say what is desirable? Richardson assumes we all desire the same thing (i.e. deep learning) and does not say why it is desirable. Personally I don't think it necessarily is!

  1. Compare Marton’s idea that some students regard learning as something that just happens to them with Sfard’s account that you read in Week 3.

Marton associates deep learning with active participation and surface learning with a passive expectation of being taught. On the face of it this suggests a parallel with Sfard's participaton and acquisition metaphors respectively. Being H800 this is unlikely to be the end of the story. Sfard challenges an exclusive option for one metaphor over the other if we are to understand learning in a useful way. Similarly, I bet that if you read Marton in the original he would say something like all learning has aspects of both....

You may not have encountered the literature that I describe. In Week 4, Chris Jones asked you to think about your own definition of ‘learning’.
  1. Do the concepts, theories and evidence described in my paper fit your own experience as a learner?

Yes, but my first encounter with Saljo (1979) was when I was studying for my PG Cert in Teaching and Learning which was in 2001 or so, so it's become part of the way I think about my experience of learning. I definitely feel that over my lifetime learning journey I have travelled further down the scale. I was intrigued by Van Rossum and Taylor (1987) with the addition of the sixth conception. Personally I would see this as a conceptualisation of research rather than learning, but it has certainly given me something to think about.

Which of Säljö’s five conceptions of learning best fits your own definition?

I think #4 (abstraction of meaning) at the moment, with aspirations to #5 (interpretative process) when I am a bit cleverer.

Post some notes in your blog, and then check what other students have written.
  1. If you have (or have had) a role in teaching or training, do the concepts, theories and evidence described in my paper fit your own experience as a teacher or trainer?

Kember 1997's list was interesting. I worry about whether or not the questions I ask in assignments or exams are 'reasonable' in terms of the material I have required students to study and the cognitive/key skills I can expect them to display. So, in spite of my pretensions to sophistication, I guess I am a bit of a #2 (transmitting structured knowledge) sort of guy! Hope to reach #5 (facilitating conceptual change) one day, but may have to rethink my approach to curriculum in the process. 

  1. If you haven’t had such a role, ask your tutor whether they fit their experience as a teacher.

  2. Do you find my argument convincing? I agree that research that illuminates 'the interplay between the view of stduent learnign shown in Figure 1 and the view of teaching shown in Figure 2' is probably a good idea -- but it struck me from the paper that the two things were sides of the same coin, so I'm not sure what the big questions to answer would be.
  3. You may find the similarity between the models in Figure 1 and Figure 2 beguiling, but are the models really justified? I thought it was quite helpful as a way of summarising the overall 'take-out' from the research reviewed, but suspiciously simple. It made me wonder what you might have left out.
Jot down some notes in your blog, check what other students have written and then check my suggestions in the discussion.
Permalink
Share post