Notes on Conole et al. (2007) Disruptive technologies etc
Sunday 15 May 2011 at 08:57
Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Terry O'Sullivan, Sunday 15 May 2011 at 08:57
Starts by questining disruptive t. as part of elearning rhetoric -- but something going on.
Prob identified by Sharpe et al (2005) that our thinking about student use of t is informed by data from course evaluations rather than a wider perspective [But I'd have thought data at this level would give more practical pointers for educators? Wider would be interesting, but a bit too vague?]
S et al (2005) call for studies of diversity of studetn use of t in formal studies [so why not course eval?] and their perception of t. [Still no definition offered, other than by implication, of 'student voice'].
'learner stories on their experiences of elearning' -- story so far.
Oblinger and Oblinger (2005): net gen different: task oriented experiential learners, like quick info, multi taskers, savvy. [So what's new?]
Kennedy et al (2006) looked at students use of technology to communicate, publish and share info -- policy implications thereof.
Kirkwood and Price (2005) OU 5yr study-- increase in use, but differences across disciplines [Why is this a metaanalysis?]
So -- tech an influence, but we need to know more...
De Laat (2006) what students do: co-ordinate and regulate personal and shared learning activities [what does that look like in practice?]. Other research concurs that 'students are activlely involved in co-designing their e-learning environments'(p. 513) [again, what does that look like?]
This study:
how do learners experience elearnng (broad def)?
role of elearning in howle learning experience?
4 subject areas looked at
Medicine etc
Economics
ICSciences
Languages etc
Methods: online survey (427), audio logs (85)(phone in diaries) and interviews (14). Claims triangulation as well as richness. Purposive sampling.
[what's the diff between subject and discipline?]
Findings:
Used for
Info seeking and handling: [ google essay titles! Thinking by proxy to understand what it might mean. Some evidence of 'mix and match' info evaluation through comparing sources. Importance of peer word of mouth. Disconnect, as I read it, between article narrative and quotes -- open to interpretation?]
Communication [pros and cons, eg. interruptions from IM. Ambivalence re discussion forums! 'often they are not used properly' -- evidence of the creation of 'their own social network to support their learning' (p. 517) -- again, what does this actually look like?]
Assignment prep [stuff about PPt - dissatisfaction that other students are better at it so advantaged in assessment -- but that's a student perception of criteria, probably not at all relevant to assessor.]
Integration [VLEs basically -- one stop shop is good. But anxiety about loosing face to face contact 'did not provide the same quality, value for money, or degree of interaction'.]
Discussion - LEX and LXP wrapped together here [what happened to our two original questions?]
Confirms O&O(2005) impression of 'students are adept at finding and manipulating relevant information and synthesising across different information sources and use a variety fo communication tools to support their learnign needs.... a shift from passive to more interactive interactions across all aspects of their learning' So, as K at al (2006)say 'Universities are ill-equipped to educate a new geneation of learners whose sophisticated use of emerging technologies is incompatible with current teaching practice' (cit. p. 519, no page ref tut tut). But should we invade their social space with our stuff?
Not much evidence of discipline differences
But subject specfic resources, of course, and how tools were used was influenced by nature of subject or activity. Eg economics -- news websites.
Subject cultural norms: eg computer studies tend to publish on mailing lists and blogs alongside formal outlets.
Educators (HEA) expectations of technology use much as expected on tribal lines (e.g. team work facilitation important for health etc.) plus SOLE project (Timmis et al 2004) repored 'marked differences n the role of tutors and their use of t across differnent dispciplies'. [How much of this is how people see themselves rather than what they do? Is it relevant anyway?]
Data reveals how much students depend on peers [has this not always been the case -- 'what was the homework again?'etc -- but underlined by t]
Summarised 8 factors re student use of tech:
pervasive
personalised
adaptive
organised
transferable
time/space boundaries
changing working patterns
integrated
[some of these could be collapsed into each other I think]
Students comfortable with t., sophisticated users (mainly), have expectations.
Notes on Conole et al. (2007) Disruptive technologies etc
Starts by questining disruptive t. as part of elearning rhetoric -- but something going on.
Prob identified by Sharpe et al (2005) that our thinking about student use of t is informed by data from course evaluations rather than a wider perspective [But I'd have thought data at this level would give more practical pointers for educators? Wider would be interesting, but a bit too vague?]
S et al (2005) call for studies of diversity of studetn use of t in formal studies [so why not course eval?] and their perception of t. [Still no definition offered, other than by implication, of 'student voice'].
'learner stories on their experiences of elearning' -- story so far.
Oblinger and Oblinger (2005): net gen different: task oriented experiential learners, like quick info, multi taskers, savvy. [So what's new?]
Kennedy et al (2006) looked at students use of technology to communicate, publish and share info -- policy implications thereof.
Kirkwood and Price (2005) OU 5yr study-- increase in use, but differences across disciplines [Why is this a metaanalysis?]
So -- tech an influence, but we need to know more...
De Laat (2006) what students do: co-ordinate and regulate personal and shared learning activities [what does that look like in practice?]. Other research concurs that 'students are activlely involved in co-designing their e-learning environments'(p. 513) [again, what does that look like?]
This study:
how do learners experience elearnng (broad def)?
role of elearning in howle learning experience?
4 subject areas looked at
Medicine etc
Economics
ICSciences
Languages etc
Methods: online survey (427), audio logs (85)(phone in diaries) and interviews (14). Claims triangulation as well as richness. Purposive sampling.
[what's the diff between subject and discipline?]
Findings:
Used for
Info seeking and handling: [ google essay titles! Thinking by proxy to understand what it might mean. Some evidence of 'mix and match' info evaluation through comparing sources. Importance of peer word of mouth. Disconnect, as I read it, between article narrative and quotes -- open to interpretation?]
Communication [pros and cons, eg. interruptions from IM. Ambivalence re discussion forums! 'often they are not used properly' -- evidence of the creation of 'their own social network to support their learning' (p. 517) -- again, what does this actually look like?]
Assignment prep [stuff about PPt - dissatisfaction that other students are better at it so advantaged in assessment -- but that's a student perception of criteria, probably not at all relevant to assessor.]
Integration [VLEs basically -- one stop shop is good. But anxiety about loosing face to face contact 'did not provide the same quality, value for money, or degree of interaction'.]
Discussion - LEX and LXP wrapped together here [what happened to our two original questions?]
Confirms O&O(2005) impression of 'students are adept at finding and manipulating relevant information and synthesising across different information sources and use a variety fo communication tools to support their learnign needs.... a shift from passive to more interactive interactions across all aspects of their learning' So, as K at al (2006)say 'Universities are ill-equipped to educate a new geneation of learners whose sophisticated use of emerging technologies is incompatible with current teaching practice' (cit. p. 519, no page ref tut tut). But should we invade their social space with our stuff?
Not much evidence of discipline differences
But subject specfic resources, of course, and how tools were used was influenced by nature of subject or activity. Eg economics -- news websites.
Subject cultural norms: eg computer studies tend to publish on mailing lists and blogs alongside formal outlets.
Educators (HEA) expectations of technology use much as expected on tribal lines (e.g. team work facilitation important for health etc.) plus SOLE project (Timmis et al 2004) repored 'marked differences n the role of tutors and their use of t across differnent dispciplies'. [How much of this is how people see themselves rather than what they do? Is it relevant anyway?]
Data reveals how much students depend on peers [has this not always been the case -- 'what was the homework again?'etc -- but underlined by t]
Summarised 8 factors re student use of tech:
pervasive
personalised
adaptive
organised
transferable
time/space boundaries
changing working patterns
integrated
[some of these could be collapsed into each other I think]
Students comfortable with t., sophisticated users (mainly), have expectations.