Edited by Terry O'Sullivan, Monday 10 October 2011 at 10:54
I've been thinking about this since coming across Locke and Hume in A222 Book 1.
I'm pretty sure I am me, and that the persons to whom I relate in life are themselves as well. While Locke emphasises the forensic in personal identity, I'd see it as more positive -- if I'm not me how can I learn or grow or develop (I suppose I do entertain a dynamic view of self, I optimistically believe in personal change and change in general) as well as be responsible or deserving. But I'm trying to bracket these self-interested (!) views while answering this question (Activity on p. 73 of Book 1).
I experience myself in trivial but surprising ways -- e.g. habits of interrupting others, finding myself driving in a particular direction out of habit when I should be going somewhere else, losing things and knowing that usually I have put them somewhere high up rather than low down in a room, liking certain types of music but not others (though my tastes are pretty catholic, I have never really 'got' jazz I regret to say), prejudices (more difficult to spot, acknowledge and change than opinions) and so on. All of these things are like a rather shadowy presence which manifests itself now and then, often a bit uncomfortably, but alows me to discover something about 'myself' which I can then be conscious of (at least for a bit) and try to do something about.
I like Kant's idea of the self as a kind of structuring mechanism (Simon Blackburn in the 'Hume on the self' audio) -- I'm sure that I filter my experiences through the person I am already, which is a bit sad as it means I'm condemned to remain the same unless I watch myself carefully. And of course, watching myself means there must be something to watch. Doesn't it?
Do I ever have a direct experience of myself?
I've been thinking about this since coming across Locke and Hume in A222 Book 1.
I'm pretty sure I am me, and that the persons to whom I relate in life are themselves as well. While Locke emphasises the forensic in personal identity, I'd see it as more positive -- if I'm not me how can I learn or grow or develop (I suppose I do entertain a dynamic view of self, I optimistically believe in personal change and change in general) as well as be responsible or deserving. But I'm trying to bracket these self-interested (!) views while answering this question (Activity on p. 73 of Book 1).
I experience myself in trivial but surprising ways -- e.g. habits of interrupting others, finding myself driving in a particular direction out of habit when I should be going somewhere else, losing things and knowing that usually I have put them somewhere high up rather than low down in a room, liking certain types of music but not others (though my tastes are pretty catholic, I have never really 'got' jazz I regret to say), prejudices (more difficult to spot, acknowledge and change than opinions) and so on. All of these things are like a rather shadowy presence which manifests itself now and then, often a bit uncomfortably, but alows me to discover something about 'myself' which I can then be conscious of (at least for a bit) and try to do something about.
I like Kant's idea of the self as a kind of structuring mechanism (Simon Blackburn in the 'Hume on the self' audio) -- I'm sure that I filter my experiences through the person I am already, which is a bit sad as it means I'm condemned to remain the same unless I watch myself carefully. And of course, watching myself means there must be something to watch. Doesn't it?