OU blog

Personal Blogs

Liberation from the self

Visible to anyone in the world

Just read the Parfit extract in the reader and thought I'd post a few thoughts.

  • It was a lot easier to understand than I had been led to believe (if I have, of course, understood it smile) but this might be because of having listened to the audio stuff a couple of times already and, of course, having had the benefit of the course texts as well. But certainly more straightforward than Locke or Hume by a long way.
  • At the same time I find his language odd -- would 'quaint' be the word? Determined to use what sound like everyday, conversational words. e.g. 'Can this matter much?'.  Or 'my death seems to me less bad'. Some times some very precise, but weird, periphrasis is necessary for him to point the distinction between what we tend to believe and what is 'true'. Plus the emphasis on things being 'hard to believe'.
  • This contributes to the impression I got reading him of a very original mind -- certainly seeing and expressing things in a way which defamiliarises them for me.
  • I was also struck by the emotional content -- the sense of genuine relief he conveys when talking about how his 'belief' changed; of being able to get out of the 'glass tunnel' and feel more connected to others. Very striking reference to Hume's 'darkness and utter loneliness' as well -- must look that up (Treatise Book 1, part iv, section 7, para 8 according to Cottingham's footnote).

I feel different about Parfit now -- a bit more receptive perhaps? Certainly I will never watch Star Trek the same way again...

Permalink Add your comment
Share post

Comments

New comment

I enjoy reading your comments. You certainly appear to have a better grasp of much of the course materials  than I do so far.

Posting such as this, I find far more helpful, in examining my own developing thoughts, than I do my present Group Forum, which for the past week, has produced nothing at all in terms of any comments on what we are currently dealing with.

Then again, maybe I'm the only one that is grasping to understand much of it. The deathly silence of the forum makes one reluctant to appear to be a too frequent contributor and, thereby, possibly indicating firmed opinions which I certainly don't yet have.

I'll be glad when my interminable questions coalesce into some form of opinions.

 

New comment

 Terry, I wasn't sure which 'term' you meant, so here goes:

Book 1 The Self.

'Forensic' see pages 15; 19; 36; 40; 41; 47; 51; 99; 113; 125;

culpability. ; p36

responsibility pages 15; 17; 19; 22; 23; 33; 36; 37; 41; 47; 51; 99; 113;

moral: pages 22; 23; 33; 36; 37; 47; 51; 99; 113;

Also see Index.

New comment

Many thanks for the references -- it was tracking down the term 'forensic' that was giving me the headache.approve