What surprises me is how little these words have changed in a thousand years, and also that if you speak them aloud, articulating all the letters, you get a kind of feel from how they might have sounded then.
| an |
forma |
| twa |
oðer |
| ðreo |
ðridda |
| feower |
feorða |
| fif |
fifta |
| siex |
siexta |
| seofon |
seofoða |
| eahta |
eahtoða |
| nigon |
nigoða |
| tien |
teoða |
forma and oðer have been replaced by first (which looks like a natural vowel and then consonant shift perhaps, I think the German is erste) and second, from Latin secundus.