OU blog

Personal Blogs

New photo

Comparing Greece and Germany H817 Activity 4 Part 2

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Steve Bamlett, Wednesday, 8 Jun 2016, 21:47


Average performance  of 15 yr olds in:

OECD Average

Difference between OECD Average and Greece

Difference between OECD Average and Germany

Difference between boys & girls performance

 y           reading

496

- 21

+ 12

Greece                                                                                                                                                   50 to girls Germany                                                                                                                                                 44 to girls

maths

494

-  41

+ 20

Greece 8 to boys

Germany                                                                                                                                                 14 to boys

science literary

501

- 34

+ 43

Greece 13 to girls

Germany                                                                                                                                                 1 to girls

 

The discrepancy between Greece and Germany at national levels in relation to average performance is startling (particularly for science literacy and maths). Gender differences are similar in both countries, suggesting that this is an effect of national characteristics that can’t be attributed to cultural differences in an easy way.

However, they may be attributable to national debt effects (reduced services and family incomes, as well as low expectations amongst school-leavers for employment).

My belief is that this economic difference is likely to be much greater than any effect of any adjustments that learning analytics is capable or competent of producing – especially given the exceptionally high correlation (highest in OECD) of socio-economic status and access to preparatory education in Greece.

I’m as sure as I can be that no stealth assessment will help to raise Greek performance without overt attention to the deliberate impoverishment of Greece brought about by EEC demands that the answer to the problems of the Greek economy must lie in reductions in national public spending and economic deflation. In fact Greece is being deliberately underdeveloped by more developed economies like Germany for getting above itself politically. Although, of course the corruption in the internal system hasn't helped.

In fact, I can’t see what the question here is getting at, since no conclusions can be arrived at where learning analytics is the first line of response to bring about change.  

All the best

Steve


Permalink Add your comment
Share post