OU blog

Personal Blogs

Richard Walker

Buttered Toast

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Tuesday, 27 Jun 2017, 23:23

It's well known that

A. Buttered toast always falls buttered side down.

B. Cats always land on their feet.

An old joke asks what would happen if we strapped a slice of buttered toast on a cat's back, buttered side up, and dropped the pair. Would toast and cat spin frantically round their common axis as they descended?

This is farcical of course, but reminds me of a though-experiment by Galileo. In Galileo's time many believed that heavy objects fell faster than light ones. Very well, asked Galileo, what would happen if we connected a heavy objects and a light one with a piece of cord, and let them fall?

The Tao of Toast

Another old joke concerns a monk who dropped his buttered toast and it landed buttered side UP!!!

In a state of great perturbation he scurried off to see the Abbott.

"Father", he said, "I am an old man and have eaten much buttered toast in my time. My toast often falls from my weak old fingers and heretofore it has always landed with the buttered side down. Today it was buttered side up. Father, does this prodigy foretell the end of ages, the second coming, and the day of judgement?"

The Abbot answered, "My Son be calm and do not disturb yourself. The explanation is simple. You buttered the toast on the wrong side."

Permalink Add your comment
Share post

Comments

Me in a rare cheerful mood

New comment

Cut the slices in half, then butter them, then drop them.  Sorted.

(If that doesn't work, I refer you to Murphy's Second Law.)

Richard Walker

New comment

Hmm. Is this a toasted sandwich?

Me in a rare cheerful mood

New comment

Funnily enough, there's a suggestion in the Viz Top Tips in the current issue, which I received just yesterday.

Basically it says if this problem bothers you, drop the toast before you butter it then pick it up and butter the side that was facing up.

Richard Walker

New comment

Cats can lick their backs. So I reckon the cat would lick the butter off.


Me in a rare cheerful mood

New comment

The cat could, but it would be spinning in mid-air just above the ground until it had done so.

Richard Walker

New comment

If it were Schrodinger's toast, wouldn't the cat's position remain indeterminate until the butter had been licked?