OU blog

Personal Blogs

Richard Walker

There Were Two Ravens

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Sunday, 17 Jun 2018, 11:20

Picture credit: my brother Simon Walker


Odin, in Old Norse, Woden in Old English, traditionally had a pair of ravens, one perched on each shoulder. According to the Poetic Edda they were named Higgunn and Minun; 'Thought' and 'Memory'. Other traditions say he taught his birds to talk.

Each day they went out gathering intelligence for Odin's ears, but he was anxious. In the Poetic Edda we read

Huginn ok Munin 
fljúga hverjan dag 
Jörmungrund yfir; 
óumc ek of Hugin 
at hann aftr né comiþ, 
þó siámc meir um Munin.

Even though a thousand years has passed since this was written down, and in Old Norse, modern English speakers can get the gist. The verse has been translated many times by modern scholars and poets, but here is my attempt. I have tried to show how we can recognise the words of long ago still in our modern speech, and identify with the thoughts and emotion of the original.

Huginn and Munin 
Fly every day
The great world over
I fear for Hugin
That after he won't come
Though I fret more on Munin.

Huginn and Munin would have been common ravens, a large crow found all over the Northern Hemisphere. Recent genetic research has suggested this bird has two species that may have started diverging before a million years ago. But even more recent research indicates these lineages are coming together again!



We mostly think of evolution as divergence, as in the left-hand sketch above. But it's perfectly possible for species to reunite, as in the right-hand sketch. And common ravens are apparently interbreeding, and doing just this. [1]

It looks like we (humans) also did this, with Neandertals and Denisovans. In their DNA is enough evidence to classify them as separate species from us; but in our DNA enough traces to show there was interbreeding. And so, like the ravens, we show that species can merge, as well as diverge.

Permalink Add your comment
Share post