OU blog

Personal Blogs

Stylised image of a figure dancing

Making Baubles

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Martin Cadwell, Saturday 14 November 2026 at 07:58

All my posts: https://learn1.open.ac.uk/mod/oublog/view.php?u=zw219551

or search for 'martin cadwell -caldwell' Take note of the position of the minus sign to eliminate caldwell returns or search for 'martin cadwell blog' in your browser.

I am not on YouTube or social media

Opinion  

Making Baubles

[ 3 minute read ]

While typing up notes I was considering how people fail to clearly see the goal. While studying for a degree in Creative Writing the overall goal is, for many people, to be a published writer. Of course it is a bi-partite route to success to study at degree level for acclaim in the wider world. First the degree and then the success, right? It's an ego thing.

We might ask why study at all? Is it to get a good grade or is it to learn a subject or craft? Why put yourself through a period of learning, which for a great many people is just plain uncomfortable; not uncomfortable to take information in, but to re-shape themselves to be effectively empty vessels for new information. It is no use bringing our talent or skill or knowledge to a course or module and expect good grades. The tests or exams are looking for what the student has learnt. If the student has learnt nothing, then typically only their own prior knowledge will be evident in their offerings and submissions for marking. That might be useful for a Masters degree or as part of a PhD (I don't know) but I think a self-taught and highly disciplined individual might struggle to get a good grade in a very much circumscribed academic environment. Take for example a skilled manual worker; spent forty years restoring classic cars; beautiful welding; fine upholstering; etc. Now let them do a theory test. No, sorry. This person doesn't know what the test is looking for. They may have no idea why feeding gas, or wire, at different rates does different things; oh, it sticks (welds) well enough but what is the tensile strength due to the addition of new components? 

I got an excellent score for a piece of creative writing in a Tutor-marked Assessment. I wouldn't write like that in real life. To me, it is rubbish; my rubbish; a waste of my time. It had none of the things I value in a good read and likely everything that the mainstream market values; I haven't checked and I shan't. That is not to say that anyone else who wrote the identical words as mine is writing rubbish; they probably are not, because they feel the words; I just write them. The thing is, the mainstream market is content with any formula that satisfies their needs. Essentially, this means that only a number of baubles need to hung on a boring tree and everyone says, 'Oooh! Wow!' and here's the thing, 'Oh look. If you start at the top of the tree and look at each bauble and work your way down you get a story!' Marvelous! What about the tree? Forget about it. No-one expecting to get high marks for their offerings in a Tutor-Marked Assessment brings their own tree. Likewise, no-one takes their own tree or method to work. The tree is not important; it is the production of pretty things that is important and how make them. 

I worked in Holland, the part of The Netherlands that is geographically closest to Britain, for a while. One of my first jobs was to pack bulbs (garden flower bulbs) in boxes bound for English addresses. Yep, this is how to do it. Not me! I put a couple of Eurocents in a few of the boxes. Why? Because while I worked in The Netherlands, the Euro was implemented as the new European currency. No member of the public had actually seen the coins or notes and certainly not touched any. That lovely lady in England with a wicker basket on her bicycle and flowers round her hat would be among the first to see the Eurocents if the metal detectors at the British customs checks didn't find them first. She might hand them over to her small grandchildren via her own children as a source of wonderment. I took my own tree to work in that factory. Oh yes, the Eurocents were extra baubles but the effect of them was not the aim; the sentiment behind the discovery of the Eurocents was my goal. That is what I was aiming at.

In places where we are tested; periodically at work, or throughout a learning or studying period, it is no use trying to buck the system. We have to give them what they want. I have to bite my tongue and refrain from saying, 'Yeah,  know. I haven't learnt anything yet.' Instead, I have to provide evidence that I have learnt something, even if I have to pretend. The creative piece I got good marks for fulfilled the criteria for the assessment, that's all. The excellent score confers upon that work that it might be an example ready for consideration to publish similar material. Not on your Nelly! I am only providing that bumpf to get the marks. I know what the assessment is testing and I put that in; my style and preferences don't come into it. The creative piece I was marked on is not for my chosen target-market; not even close. I am working on developing the tree and not the baubles. I have no wish to titillate or shock. I have no desire to invoke emotion in the reader; I only do it because that is what is expected of me.

There are students who submitted their own assignments to be assessed similarly to my own. I suspect they wrote how they wanted to write in the genre they like and they carried forth tired and worn ideas because that is what they are comfortable with. The assessment was looking for specific things; if you put them in you get good marks; if you leave them out you don't get good marks. Yet, there is a trick that not many people may have considered. The next assessment tests for other things; so practice putting those things in the assessments that precedes any necessity to provide that evidence of learning and see how it works. If you get it wrong it doesn't matter. The thing is we get comfortable with the feel of the superfluous addition before we need to demonstrate our capability to provide it.

I have to take half a day to recover when I realise that there is an expectation that my work will further develop in a prescribed manner that suits a mainstream audience. If I had to operate in an environment that demands mediocre content and production for a living it would be work and I would want to do something else that I would enjoy.

Don't forget we cannot take our own tree to work, unless we own the business.

Permalink Add your comment
Share post