I am reading a 52 piece part work 'World War' edited by Sir John Hammerton and published between 1936 and 1937 with occasional contributions from H G Wells, this alongside various staple and new reads on World War One.
As a piece of learning design what could be simpler? A magazine delivered each week, chapters deliberately left unfinished between parts, photos offering points of interest explained and developed in later issues.
Perspectives shift of course, just as they had a view on the Napoleonic Wars. However, in many cases 1914 was not dissimilar to a battle of 1814, or 1870.
'Read in a period until you hear its people speak' E H Carr.
I play this trick of falling asleep with an event in mind and courtesy of the painkillers I am currently taking I enter a vivid dream world much of which I can recall.
The problem with WW1 is the clammer of voices, not just what you can read, but the voices you can listen to on DVD or podcasts, indeed I have several hours of my own grandfather in a County Durham accent that those not familiar with the North East would call Geordie and find, at times, incomprehensible.
How does an historian deal with history when the record is everything? Had a soldier gone into battle in 1914 with a video headset what would we do today with years of material? My grandfather, for example, had no leave from the day he left England in early 1916 to his transfer to the Royal Flying Corps at the very end of 1917.
Would the reality be a huge amount of sitting around dealing with the boredom, discomfort and fear?
This is a map I drew with my grandfather in his 97th year. This and his visit to the trenches the previous year would allow me to retrace his steps, almost by the day between September and end of December 1917.
A researcher from UCL quizzed me on this some years ago and I had to conclude that for me it was less an obsession with WW1, but rather reminding me of a dearly loved grandparent. I can't see drawing up maps of my grandmother's trips into Newcastle on the tram having the same appeal (or historical record or value).
Gradually online I am connecting with grandchildren of veterans and others interested in WW1 so that there is a component of 'Social Learn' between blogs and Facebook. All the books I read I share on Twitter, which may help promote the book, but is also attracting many like-minds.
At what point do I become so well informed that I could sit an exam without sitting for the qualification?
Can I short-circuit the steps to an MA in History? There are two parts to the degree, but it is the second part, the ellective, that takes me into WW1 territory.
Hi Jonathan..Have you read 'In Parenthesis' by David Jones..with whom,I think,the first world war was his obsession and world. The introduction of modern weaponry makes it different to other wars,don't you think..I have read that the British were proud of the fact that the first blow struck during the First confrontation with the 'enemy' was struck with a sword. Jones stated he felt a rubicon had been passed with the introduction of hand grenades etc.. instead of man conrtolling weaponry,weaponry controlled man.
really interesting post.
I'll read it asap.
Indeed an extraordinary set of conflicts as various wannabe nations decided to felx their muscles.
Looking back through several hundreds years whilst the technology and habits had them stuck for a while and the numbers that were slaughtered en masse were horrendous it doesn't change the fact that the human body is vulnerable to wounding and fatal injury, even oblivion.
Any modern soldier has everything in common with soldiers before them when it comes to injury.
I was just wondering if all that effort and cost and thought that was put into war could be galvanised for peace ... the expenditure, inventiveness and ludicrous man hours?
What could we build or fix in four years if several million fit young people were set to the task?
New commentP.S. I would have hand the Kindle version of In Parenthesis in the last 60 seconds, instead for $4.99 I'll wait for tomorrow's post and accept that if I want to share its contents I'll have to type out key thoughts rather than uploading to Twitter!