OU blog

Personal Blogs

Dave Edwards in Edinburgh

S207 Quantum mechanics with Elluminate

Visible to anyone in the world

This is another new tutorial topic for me! The tutorial falls in the early part of S207's Book 7. Therefore I only really need to consider  material on reasons physicists developed quantum theory, wave-particle duality, Heisenberg's uncertainty principle and the one-dimensional time-independent Schrodinger equation for square wells and barriers.

I want to emphasise physical thinking as a means of getting into the maths. The material on the Schrodinger equation is quite mathematical and complex.

I decide to focus on the role of standing waves. These could be waves in a glass of wine (or cup of coffee), or in a skipping rope. I want to show how the confinement of the waves leads to discrete wavelength values, which then give rise to discrete energy values - quantization.

I sketched some one-dimensional standing waves on a rope, and wrote down expression for the possible wavelengths in terms of the length of the rope. Then I put these values into sine and cosine wave functions. These are the permitted waves that can 'stand' on the string.

To prepare the actual tutorial material I started to build a PowerPoint presentation.  Individual slides were prepared by making use of MS Paint (sketching diagram and graph axes), constructing a series of sine and cosine graphs with Excel, and preparing images  of equations in the MS Word equation editor. Student interaction was designed in with some simple quiz questions, by asking students to sketch curves onto my graph axes, and by asking students to do their own algebra.

A copy of the PowerPoint is available here.

Permalink Add your comment
Share post
Dave Edwards in Edinburgh

Planning and delivering an S207 tutorial

Visible to anyone in the world

I decided to deal with magnetic induction first. during the planning, I working through an explanation of the topic based on Faraday's law. But then I decided instead to use last year's TMA question about the transformer. I found that I could include Faraday's law nicely within this.

In practise, this provided a useful opportunity to discuss the merits of  "remembering nothing - so there is less to forget in the exam"! The transformer equation is simply obtained directly from Faraday's law.

The lens calculation proved effective during the tutorial. Students were unclear about how to address even this simple two lens system. We discussed real and virtual images and the 'real is posiive' sign convention. I explained that the lenses are simply handled individually, in turn, working out image and then object distances.

The laser diffraction experiment went down very well. A student commented afterwards that he would have been disappointed if we had not done something like this - and he mentioned the value of our bouncing ball demonstration and discussion at the first tutorial.

The experiment task was to work out the ratio of the wavelengths of the red and green light from a laser pointer, using the grating equation. We also estimated the uncertainty. In fact we got exactly the ratio that is obtained from the wavelengths marked on the laser.  This supported the uncertainty calculation of +/-0.01

Overall this seemed to be an enjoyable session, with a strong emphasis  on using physical principles.  I could repeat this next year.

After the session I had an email from a non-attender asking for information from the tutorial. I placed versions of the transformer and lens questions on the tutor group forum, with some tips to help guide the reader.However, there was no student discussion of this material and when I spoke to the student a couple of weeks later he had clearly not used the material.

[6 March 2013]

Permalink Add your comment
Share post
Dave Edwards in Edinburgh

Planning an S207 face-to-face tutorial

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Dave Edwards, Monday 8 April 2013 at 10:02

The S207 (The physical world) tutorial is face-to-face for Book 6 (Dynamic fields and waves). It will be followed a couple of week later with an Elluminate sesion.

The topics the students should have covered at this point are time-varying magnetic fields and induction, waves and ray optics.

The TMA has questions on induction, diffraction and relativity.  I plan to leave relativity to the Elluminate session.

Last year my tutorial reviewed some tricky questions from the preceding TMA, and included a diffraction experiment for the students to carry out.

I decided that there is no need this time to review the previous TMA. I should provide something on the electrical work - emphasing physical principles.

I also found an old exam question on the use of the lens equation, which I think is instructive for sign conventions and selection of rays for ray tracing. I might extend this into a wider discussion of optics - and perhaps take along a telescope.

My own interferogram software might be used to illustrate wavefronts.

I will also take a spectroscope to allow students to look at spectra.

[6 march 2013]

Permalink Add your comment
Share post

This blog might contain posts that are only visible to logged-in users, or where only logged-in users can comment. If you have an account on the system, please log in for full access.

Total visits to this blog: 136708