OU blog

Personal Blogs

Richard Walker

Odom's Problem: Out of 74 Solutions the Winner is...

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Monday 29 June 2026 at 20:44

At the start of this month I wrote about the following problem.

Inscribe an equilateral triangle in a circle. Draw a line through the midpoints cap u and cap v of two of its sides, to meet the circle at cap w .

Show that cap u times cap v divided by cap v times cap w is equal to phi , the number of the Golden Section.


This elegant result was proposed by George Odom as problem E3007 in the American Mathematical Monthly in 1983 and the best solution out of the 74 receive was published in 1986. Here is the miraculous solution given by Jan van de Craats. I have drawn my own diagram and provided slightly more explanation but not changed the underlying proof at all. Here is the diagram above but with some additional lines and labels.

Take the length of cap v times cap w as one and suppose cap u times cap v equals f . By symmetry cap t times cap u equals one . Because the small triangle cap u times cap b times cap v is equilateral and cap v is the midpoint of cap b times cap c we have equation sequence part 1 cap v times cap c equals part 2 cap v times cap b equals part 3 f .

Because cap t and cap c are subtended on the circumference of the circle by the same arc cap b times cap w the angles there are equal. Angles cap t times cap v times cap b and cap c times cap v times cap w are equal, because they are vertically opposite. Hence triangles cap t times cap v times cap b and cap c times cap v times cap w are similar.

The ratios of corresponding pairs of sides in these two triangle must therefore be equal, so we have 

one divided by f equals f divided by one plus f

and rearranging gives one plus f equals f squared or f squared minus f minus one equals zero , the equation whose positive root is phi , the number of the Golden Section.

(Jan van de Craats' write-up was terser; he just gave the diagram above and underneath wrote

f squared equals f plus one

relying on the Intersecting Chords Theorem, but I thought it would be better to use similar triang;es and not assume knowledge of that theorem.)

Footnote: I quite liked my own proof but the one above is far, far nicer, which I suppose is the reason it got published. Mine was a worthy effort but really just an 'also ran', along with the 74 other ARs.

Permalink
Share post

This blog might contain posts that are only visible to logged-in users, or where only logged-in users can comment. If you have an account on the system, please log in for full access.

Total visits to this blog: 6184308