OU blog

Personal Blogs

Design Museum

The Art of Getting Lost: From Oxford Libraries to AI

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Jonathan Vernon, Sunday 15 November 2026 at 09:02

A mindburst: A billion ping-pong balls ricocheting through the nuclear reactor of my imagination, as human curiosity encounters artificial intelligence.

What twenty-first-century technology has taught me about the learning theories I studied at the Open University.

What do I miss from the old days?

Not much, as it happens.

I’ve lived through the Moon landings, the arrival of personal computers, the Internet, the World Wide Web, smartphones and now artificial intelligence.

I’m 65, and I hope to witness another thirty years of extraordinary technological change.

But there’s one experience I remember with particular affection.

Getting lost in a library.

As an undergraduate at Oxford, I could spend days following a question through the Bodleian, the Science Library, the Map Room, the Rhodes Library and the reading rooms containing historical newspapers.

One reference led to another.

A journal suggested a map. The map raised another question. A footnote sent me searching for something entirely unexpected.

I loved it.

One particularly memorable expedition involved an essay I’d chosen to write about breastfeeding.

I wanted to investigate its historical, anthropological, physiological and educational significance.

How did mothers and infants learn to breastfeed? How did the experience differ across cultures? What did biology determine, and what was socially learned?

It sent me everywhere.

Among my discoveries was the hormonal mechanism through which breastfeeding could delay ovulation.

Several years later, in April 1988, I was back in Newcastle, working as a television producer.

My sister had a six-month-old baby boy.

Naturally, I enthusiastically shared what I’d learned about breastfeeding and fertility.

I must have been convincing.

The following February, she gave birth to a daughter.

She’s blamed me ever since.

Apparently, she had understood my explanation to mean that breastfeeding would reliably prevent another pregnancy.

It doesn’t.

My sister went on to have five children and now has seven grandchildren.

But I still get the blame.

Quite a result for an undergraduate essay.

From library shelves to learning theory

When I began studying for my Masters in Open and Distance Education at the OU, I became fascinated by the theories that might explain what was happening when we learned.

Constructivism. Social constructivism. Situated learning. Communities of practice. Activity theory. Metacognition.

I devoured them.

Looking back, my Oxford library expeditions provide an interesting example of several of these ideas in practice.

I wasn’t simply receiving information.

I was actively constructing an understanding, drawing connections between disciplines, testing explanations and discovering that each answer generated further questions.

The libraries, catalogues, books and maps were tools.

My tutors and fellow students were part of a community.

The academic disciplines had their own conventions, assumptions and expectations.

And I was trying to produce something meaningful from the interaction.

Sound familiar?

Engeström enters the room

Yrjö Engeström’s Activity Theory model particularly appealed to me.

It offered a way of understanding learning not simply as something happening inside an individual’s head, but as an activity mediated by tools, social relationships, rules and shared objectives.

The familiar triangle had its subject, object, tools, community, rules and division of labour.

I could use it to examine my undergraduate research.

And I can use it again today.

Only the tools have changed.

Instead of searching catalogues and travelling between libraries, I might begin with a question to an AI.

The AI retrieves, explains, compares, challenges and suggests connections.

I respond.

It responds.

Another question emerges.

And off we go again.

Except that Engeström’s model also encourages us to consider contradictions.

A tool that gives me immediate access to information might also encourage me to accept an answer before properly examining it.

Something that makes research easier might make certain intellectual shortcuts more tempting.

An AI capable of proposing a plausible explanation might also produce one that is completely wrong.

The tool changes the activity.

And the activity changes how I learn.

The curious case of my AI companion

Here’s something that made me smile.

I’ve recently been using AI to explore an archive of more than 3,750 entries from my OU student blog.

In March 2013, I wrote a post titled:

“Right now I need an AI Companion.”

Thirteen years later, here I am.

I have one.

Well, something approaching what I imagined.

And I find myself returning to questions I was asking during my MAODE studies.

What constitutes meaningful interaction?

Can a machine provide useful scaffolding?

Where does the learner’s agency reside?

What is the relationship between receiving an explanation and developing an understanding?

When does reflection become learning?

What happens when the technology can participate in something resembling a tutorial dialogue?

And perhaps most importantly, how do I know when I’ve actually learned something?

A billion ping-pong balls

Early this morning, I was discussing these ideas with an AI.

One recollection prompted another. I remembered my grandfather learning to fly in 1918, my Oxford libraries, my sister’s unexpected baby, the educational technologies we experimented with during my Masters, and the extraordinary possibilities of AI.

My brain felt as though a billion ping-pong balls were ricocheting around a nuclear reactor hall.

Ideas everywhere.

Connections forming.

Questions multiplying.

I was having a wonderful time.

And suddenly I recognised the experience.

It was remarkably like getting lost in those Oxford libraries.

Not identical, of course.

There’s no substitute for the physical presence of other people, the unexpected conversation, the tutorial, the argument over a whiteboard or the sensory experience of books and places.

But the intellectual excitement was familiar.

It also made me reconsider the educational technologies we experimented with during the MAODE.

Some now seem almost comically crude.

Yet the questions we were asking about learning design, social interaction, learner autonomy and the mediation of learning remain remarkably relevant.

Perhaps more relevant than ever.

What comes next?

I’ve begun imagining a new kind of library.

Not simply shelves of books, but galleries, archives, studios, music, games, laboratories, swimming pools, places to eat, and spaces for conversation and argument.

Somewhere people could learn through every available medium.

A physical community connected to an almost limitless digital world.

A place where an unexpected encounter might lead to an entirely new intellectual adventure.

It’s beginning to look suspiciously like the Oxbridge campus I enjoyed so much.

But I’d want it to be open to everyone.

And perhaps that’s the most important connection to my Open University experience.

The opportunity to participate in learning shouldn’t depend upon age, background, income or whether you’ve ever attended a university.

Technology can widen that opportunity.

But technology alone doesn’t create a learning community.

People do.

So what do I miss from the old days?

The pleasure of getting lost in knowledge.

Except that I haven’t really lost it.

I’ve simply found another way to wander.

And I’d love to know whether other OU graduates feel the same.

Has technology fundamentally changed the way you learn, or has it simply given your curiosity new places to explore?

References and further reading

Engeström, Y. (1987). Learning by Expanding: An Activity-Theoretical Approach to Developmental Research.

Engeström, Y. (2001). ‘Expansive Learning at Work: Toward an Activity-Theoretical Reconceptualization.’ Journal of Education and Work, 14(1), pp. 133–156.

Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes.

Related reading: The Art of Getting Lost — the longer, personal version of this story on JVernon.blog.

Permalink Add your comment
Share post
Design Museum

70 Up: Still Becoming — An Open University Perspective

Visible to anyone in the world

What stays with me about 70 Up is the distance between the life a child imagines and the life an adult actually lives.

The Up series began with fourteen seven-year-olds in 1964, exploring how background and circumstances might shape their futures. Across the decades, it has become an extraordinary record of people growing older within a changing Britain. For me, it also raises a question familiar to many Open University students: how much of our story is already written, and how much remains open to revision?

At sixty-five (last week), I am a little younger than its participants. Nevertheless, I recognise that experience of looking back through successive versions of yourself. The child, the teenager, the young adult and the person you are today remain connected, sometimes in ways you could never have anticipated.

My own record takes the form of diaries from age 13 to my early twenties. Your adult notebooks, followed by online writing on Diaryland from September 1999, preserve what mattered to me then. Reading them now, I have to resist giving my younger self knowledge he didn't have. He could not see where his enthusiasms would lead. Neither could the man approaching fifty who returned to study with the Open University.

That uncertainty matters. It is easy to make a life look inevitable once you know what happened.

On 5 February 2010, my Diaryland entry brought together several competing ambitions: an OU module in e-learning, the possibility of studying fine art at West Dean, swimming-coach qualifications and applications for work. Substantial fees and the journey from Lewes constrained art study. Curiosity was plentiful; money and practical possibilities were less accommodating.

The following day, 6 February, I began the blog that would become my sustained exploration of learning.

Then, on 8 February, I wrote:

"Like an undergraduate again, I feel the buzz of learning new things."

That sentence still makes me smile. I had corrected the spelling here, but I would leave the excitement exactly as it was.

I compared exploring the OU library with the freedom I had once enjoyed calling up books in Oxford's Bodleian. Twenty-five years later, that appetite had returned. Alongside it, the same entry recorded anxiety about the mortgage, a cold and the swimming programme I was due to teach that evening.

Many OU students will recognise that combination. Intellectual discovery happens in a life already crowded with responsibilities. There is an assignment to finish, but also work, children, caring, bills and tiredness. The pleasure of learning does not make those demands disappear. Sometimes it gives us something sustaining.

Another Diaryland entry, from April 2010, shows a different kind of discovery. I began recognising how much of my previous career had already involved distance learning: producing videos distributed by post, satellite broadcasts, facilitated courses and interactive learning materials.

I had experience before I had the academic language to examine it.

I also wrote about the career break during which I took our children to nursery and primary school, collected them afterwards and took them swimming and sailing. Those responsibilities had helped lead me into teaching and coaching. Returning to study offered a way to bring these different periods of experience together.

For an adult student, that can be a profound change in perspective. A career interruption, an apparently unrelated job or years spent caring for others may contain knowledge that has gone unrecognised. Study gives us concepts to question it, connections to understand it, and opportunities to develop it further.

My MA in Open and Distance Education gave structure and challenge to my curiosity. Across seven modules, including Creativity, Innovation and Change, Accessible Online Learning and Researching Learning in the Digital Age, I became more demanding about the claims made for educational technology.

Who could participate? Who was being excluded? What evidence supported an approach? What did creativity require beyond an attractive tool?

Those questions have followed me into work as a Learning Technologist, into historical education with The Western Front Association, and into teaching. Further study in British history and the First World War, followed by a PGCE completed in 2022, brought fresh ways of examining practice. MOOCs and mentoring also gave me opportunities to learn alongside people with different experiences.

Looking back, I can see continuity across these activities. Living through them felt much less orderly.

That is one reason 70 Up interests me. I am wary of treating any life as a simple demonstration of an early prediction. Circumstances matter enormously. So do relationships, health, resources, encouragement and chance. We should be equally wary of claiming that determination alone allows everyone to overcome their starting point.

I benefited from educational privilege. My story cannot stand as proof that opportunity is equally available. Indeed, the barriers recorded in my own diaries remind me how much depends on being able to afford study and fit it around a life.

For me, the promise of the Open University lies in making further learning possible at stages when conventional educational routes may no longer fit.

That learning also travels beyond the qualification. At the swimming pool, it informs how I coach age group swimmers whose confidence is developing at a different pace from their performance. In council work and environmental advocacy, it shapes the questions I ask about evidence, access and responsibility. In drawing, printmaking and writing, it encourages me to keep observing and experimenting.

I still play the guitar. I still occasionally sing Bowie. I still begin things without knowing quite where they will lead.

Watching 70 Up, I therefore find myself thinking about the student opening a module website after years away from education. They bring a history with them: achievements, disappointments, responsibilities, unfinished ambitions. That history will influence how they learn. Learning may, in turn, change how they understand that history.

My diaries preserve moments when I felt stuck, distracted or uncertain. They also preserve the delight of discovering that I could become a student again.

For an OU readership, that is the reflection I want to carry forward. Seven should be a beginning, not a prediction. And at forty-eight, sixty-five or seventy, there should still be room to ask a new question—and time and support to pursue it.

Permalink Add your comment
Share post

This blog might contain posts that are only visible to logged-in users, or where only logged-in users can comment. If you have an account on the system, please log in for full access.

Total visits to this blog: 23037575