OU blog

Personal Blogs

Stylised image of a figure dancing

Now Listen Up

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Martin Cadwell, Sunday 25 October 2026 at 03:34

All my posts: https://learn1.open.ac.uk/mod/oublog/view.php?u=zw219551

or search for 'martin cadwell -caldwell' Take note of the position of the minus sign to eliminate caldwell returns or search for 'martin cadwell blog' in your browser. There is a space between my name and the minus sign and NO space before 'caldwell' to eliminate the name 'caldwell' in the Google listings

I am not on YouTube or social media

Cadwell NOT Caldwell

Opinion

Patronising Donkeys

[ 5 minute read ]

'You can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink.' I first heard that in a Laurel and Hardy skit when 'Stanley' just didn't get the concept of something. That was a long time ago when Oliver Hardy said that; likely to have been the 1930s or so. Yet, it is as true today as it might ever have been.

I find some people who just have to cling to an idea that they are right in their beliefs, or they have such confidence that they are right, that they will become pedants to fend off any negation or adaptation of their ideas through the use of any kind of, or amount of, counter-evidence. 

'Hanlon's razor is an adage or rule of thumb that states, "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity." It is a philosophical razor that promotes a way of eliminating unlikely explanations for human behavior, purportedly named after the American writer Robert J. Hanlon, who submitted the statement to Murphy's Law Book Two: More Reasons Why Things Go Wrong! (1980).'

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon's_razor

Most of us, at some time or another, have been in a situation wherein we make a statement but we lack the vocabulary to express it well. Writing our thoughts or what we know is tricky and takes a lot of practice. I think, when it comes down to it, we are all just stupid and not malicious when we cause offense. It is when someone feels maligned that they will pick on the language used as being defective. However, this usually occurs after the contributor is attacked.

       'What do you know? You can't even spell properly and the quote you made is on page seventeen and not fifteen!' In other words - this is a pedant saying, 'You are an idiot.'

I have learnt to include 'I think...'; 'I suggest...'; and 'I believe...' in a lot of my written conversations. In spoken conversation I am quite informal and that is troubling for me. I am one of those persons who thinks of a rejoinder after  I have left the scene. I think I am saying that I am not checking what I am saying, despite a lot of people saying I am measured in my speech. 

There was a philosopher, David Hume, who stated that a smile begets a smile or something like that, and crying begets crying in others. If someone gets irritated by being challenged, I, in turn, feel my emotions become elevated. Mostly, though, I am thinking 'Get a grip! Keep your conversation relevant to the issue at hand and collect your thoughts so you can shunt erroneous information to the right time and place.'

Some people are just hard work. They speak  their thoughts aloud which requires the intended recipient to pick up their carelessly flung words, reassemble them in a coherent form and relay them back to the mess of a person who chundered them up. Do your own thinking, please! Don't get me wrong; I write my thoughts down all the time and I even verbally express them, but, I delete those thoughts after I have used them to create a new position from which to later pontificate.

Writing is therapeutic and all-revealing to me. Just lately though I am finding that I am having to state that I am an idiot to people who think they, themselves, are not. I am seriously irked by positively reinforcing blather by retreating from engagement. I am getting really quite lazy though and I feel that I am increasingly using heuristics to categorise people. Just briefly looking at those compartments, I have 'Can't be bothered'; 'You're an idiot'; and 'What time is it?' to where I put people in my mind. The last, 'What time is it?' is the best and most promising place for persons to be. It means that I am considering spending some time trying to help that person to be humble.

Usually, I suggest, we can be sure whether someone is actually correct in what they say. The rest of the time, I believe, we need to help people to realise that now is a good time to back up and read a book on the subject and then try again later. 

Yesterday lunch-time, I had a weird start to a conversation in the local shop.

       'Hello, Martin. How are you.'

       'Fine, except for the news reporting. I just want facts and no emotion.' It was a hang-nail attitude I had from yesterday morning.

       'Don't talk to me about the news. They are trying to convict the SAS!' he replied.

Old news, I thought. And, it is the criminal courts with the application of our laws, and the wider nation who are trying to convict our Special Forces with their emotions, 'I wouldn't like those brutes to do that in my house!' It really doesn't matter how we feel at home in the UK, I suggest, with our limited views and experience. We are all likely to have a really quite distorted idea of how the world works. So, that topic is a dead-dog to me.

I could smell alcohol on this chap's breath and fortunately I had created a position from which I could give a measured answer. I certainly wasn't about to get drawn into a conversation that was energised by emotion. 'Facts...blah blah blah...facts!' There are no donkeys with two hind legs near where I live and I could see his eyes were glazing over, and he was drunk so I ended with, 'People's actions should not be judged by other people's emotions!' just to give him an idea that I was in agreement with whatever was going on in his head. After all, he stated that he would be able to kill and still get a good night's sleep. I doubt he was serious though; many people identify with Special Forces mentality to boost their egos. He moved on to pay for his selection at the checkout, without responding to me, but he looked a little appeased.

I have still a lot to learn about getting people to keep their raw thoughts to themselves and showing them where the pram is that they should climb back into, because I am still overwhelmingly selfish and don't devote enough time to trying to understand them.

Permalink Add your comment
Share post
Stylised image of a figure dancing

Clever Donkey

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Martin Cadwell, Sunday 11 October 2026 at 12:21

All my posts: https://learn1.open.ac.uk/mod/oublog/view.php?u=zw219551

or search for 'martin cadwell -caldwell' Take note of the position of the minus sign to eliminate caldwell returns or search for 'martin cadwell blog' in your browser. There is a space between my name and the minus sign and NO space before 'caldwell' to eliminate the name 'caldwell' in the Google listings

I am not on YouTube or social media

Cadwell NOT Caldwell

Opinion

Seriously joking, right?

[ 2 minute read ]

       'I have come to learn!'

       'Oh, alright then,' the old man in the deck-chair replied, knocking out his pipe. 'What is it you want to know?' His deeply lined face grew older as he pondered.

       'I don't know. Stuff!'

       'Do you hear that, Bonny? He wants to know stuff.' The donkey beside him looked balefully back at him. 'Have you come far, learner?' The old man asked the hesitant man. 'Are you a seeker?'

       'Not really. I just fancied learning something and thought I would show up. I borrowed the money.'

       'And?'

       'I think there are people more advanced than I in the class.'

       'And so you have not made yourself known, and because you think the money is not yours, since you borrowed it, you have not lost it?'

       'Well, yes.'

       'Embarrassed!'

The old man in the deck-chair refilled his pipe and tamped the tobacco down. He shrewdly looked at Bonny, the donkey, which winked at him and thought itself more clever than the man. The old man lit his pipe and nodded his agreement. 'Another one', he mouthed. Bonny raised and lowered her head twice.

***

There are two types of people. There are a lot more really but today there are only two. There is the person who makes the most out of their day. 'Carpe Diem' (seize the day) and there is the person who expects others to make the day for them. 'absens haeres non erit.' The latter Latin phrase means 'he who is absent will not inherit'. As far as I understand things, if someone does not bring their head to the game, the game will play without them, and that head-less person can never gain anything.

       The old man decided to speak Latin, 'spectator!' and strangely he was understood. The slumped-shouldered man before him flinched. 'You have paid to learn and yet you remain a spectator.' The old man deliberately said to Bonny the donkey. Bonny looked at the crestfallen man, who nervously looked back. He had yet to come to terms with self-actualising, the highest personal aspirational human need in Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs after basic needs are met.

       Bonny coughed, 'Ego!' but added 'Haw' to make it seem natural. She drew her lips back into a macabre yellow-toothed grin.

       'I am coming to that!' the old man said irascibly. 'Don't jump the gun.' He boosted himself up from his deck-chair, reached over to the side and down to the sand on the beach and picked up the only book there; next to a red plastic bucket and spade. The book had no title or author's name but the fly-leaf inside said, 'Simply Psychology, and it had https://www.simplypsychology.org/self-actualization.html underneath the words. It fell open at 'Potential' and he read aloud, 'Self-actualization is a concept in psychology that refers to the process of fulfilling one's true potential, becoming the best version of oneself, and achieving personal growth, meaning, and fulfillment in various aspects of life.' All the rest of the pages were blank. They always were. He put the book back down and a few grains of sand jumped onto it. It didn't matter. He was safe in the knowledge that the words would rearrange themselves, with sometimes more and sometimes less words, and some of the words would be changed into other words.

       'Were you seeking validation, approbation, praise and positive clamouring for your skill?'

       'No,'

       Bonny shook her huge head and looked directly at the man. Facing the scrutiny of a dumb animal the man cracked, 'Yes! yes, yes!'

       'Now you realise that you have been coasting and not applying yourself.'

       'Yes.'

       'All that glistens is not gold.' said Bonny finally fed up with being silent.

       'If vicarious learning was your goal then you have it.' said the old man, nodding. 'If you really want to learn, you have to work at it.' And following on from Bonny's careless outburst, 'Diamonds do not come out of the ground already cut and polished.'

       Bonny coughed again. 'Ego!' and unconvincingly added 'Haw.'

       'Flat, I should say.' observed the old man, 'But the realisation is not yet there because there is too much of an echo.' He puffed on his pipe and shut his eyes and then lifted one eye-lid to see if the follower had gone. He noticed the tide was coming in.

It is strange how an echo seems so real and provides comfort, even though it is disembodied and from the past.

Permalink Add your comment
Share post
Stylised image of a figure dancing

Thanks for the moment

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Martin Cadwell, Tuesday 11 August 2026 at 16:10

moment

All my posts: https://learn1.open.ac.uk/mod/oublog/view.php?u=zw219551

or search for 'martin cadwell -caldwell' Take note of the position of the minus sign to eliminate caldwell returns or search for 'martin cadwell blog' in your browser.

I am not on YouTube or social media

Cadwell NOT Caldwell

 

Thanks for the moment

[3 minute read ] 

Opinion and Reflection

Isn't it strange that we can get more than we bargained for, or hoped for, simply because we are 'on the list'. Suddenly we are taken seriously and the choice of words we hear from voices in the group are so much more pertinent to us than they might otherwise have been. Indeed, there are seemingly specific people within the milling crowd who are there for such a purpose as to guide more effectively than others may be able to do so. 'Ah, good evening Mr Bond! We were expecting you.'

I think it is the relevance of an approach that makes our ears 'prick up'. 'Oh, I think you are talking to me in a language you expect me to know, be interested to know, or will by default through a continuance of expected action come to know'.

Plainly, I am reluctant to outline where my experience of this focused intent is located. It is a worthwhile secret. Keeping secrets is a little bit against my deliberate attitude towards openness and honesty. However, I do understand that The Open University has good reasons for making sure its students are not too brazen with their truth. 'Woo hoo! I am on target for a first!' is wholly inappropriate, since that level of achievement is, I suspect, unusual, and so publicly celebrating one's ability to succeed is bound to cause other students to feel disappointed with their own work or ability. In any case, anyone who brays their celebration loudly is likely to alienate themselves from a group; quite simply through demonstrating a crassness that most of us consider to be an abomination.

I am not on target for any level of achievement. 'I have always despised the saying, 'That was then; this is now'. Yet, today I find it kind of fits, but only if I wrestle it to the ground and hold it still long enough to be able to deconstruct it. 

       'We used to be good friends,'

       'Yeah, that was then; this is now.'

I think the intent is to shrug off the underlying and forthcoming question of, 'Why don't you like me?' which requires a detailed explanation. 'That was then and this is now' carries with it a sentiment that the speaker considers that things have changed; time has passed and their emotions have evolved and are now directed towards more current and more emotionally rewarding issues. However, in the deconstruction of this statement I find that I can reconstruct it as 'This is now; it is not the future.' This might be said by someone sharing a bed with a person they hooked up with at a nightclub the previous night, when the other person asks for a phone number the next morning. It keeps the interaction between the two people in the present. And, just like there being a ruined expectation of a present based on the past (That was then...) there is a null expectation of a future; any imagined or expected future based on the present is quashed. Hence, anyone who says, 'I am on target for...', needs to rapidly realign their thinking. (This is now....)

Often, I would get into trouble on student forums for writing cryptic comments that, once the student has untangled their own confusion as to the task they need to undertake, may have made retrospective sense of them. No student as far as I could tell, ever figured out my clues. Of course, they would never have been allowed to offer a translation of my coded message in a forum, and it is disruptive to other students to acknowledge perspicacity and accuracy in a comment that appears not to be lucid. It may even inadvertently encourage too much time being allocated to attempting to deconstruct my code, when all it was there for was to act as a reassurance that the student had independently and correctly figured something out. The trouble came not from tutors or moderators, but from students reading my comments. 'Shut up! You are confusing us with your philosophical drivel.' is one attitude I encountered. Stop reading it then! I thought. 

It is a terrible thing to be confused. I do not have the skill and ability to leave a trail of carrots into a stable to encourage a donkey to go where it needs to be. I think it is Amazon who have the 'If you like this, you might also like this.' statement on their website. In some recent feedback I received, there were groupings of words used as focus points that indicated an education beyond my own in my chosen field of study. I know the words and I understand the meaning when they are grouped in a particular way. These focus points act as 'carrots'; not to encourage me into a smelly stable but instead out into fresh air and with new eyes to see new horizons with fresh curiousity. It makes me feel valued. I never seek validation for my efforts, and I am surprised that it snugly fits. I actually consider that to be a weakness in me in that I, for a moment or two, held onto the soft comfort of being the recipient of someone's respect. Thanks for the moment. I suppose that is not much different to 'This is now; it is not the future' but that is not the drive behind my gratitude and it is not an indication of any intended redistribution of my focus; just thanks for the time and effort that was put into the feedback; feedback that was clearly constructed with an idea of what I need and carried with it a good deal of respect. 

Permalink 1 comment (latest comment by Russell Larke, Tuesday 11 August 2026 at 17:26)
Share post

This blog might contain posts that are only visible to logged-in users, or where only logged-in users can comment. If you have an account on the system, please log in for full access.

Total visits to this blog: 1039905