OU blog

Personal Blogs

Christopher Douce

Critical reading: giving and responding to in-depth academic feedback

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Christopher Douce, Friday 20 November 2026 at 10:30

On 5 November 2026 I attended a CPD event about critical reading and the reviewing of teaching materials, facilitated by Judith Croston. The event was described as being “part of the STEM Writing for Production Programme”.  The learning outcomes were to: understand the role of academic critical reading in module production, to look at critical review templates, and understand what writers of module materials should expect from critical readers, and how to respond to feedback.

Role in quality assurance

Since module materials can have a lifetime of some considerable years, it is important that the materials are as correct and as robust as they could be. In terms of the university curriculum management guide, critical readers are described as ‘practitioners, academics and researchers with expertise in areas of knowledge and practice relevant to the module.’ They could be module authors, a module team chair, academic researchers, PhD students, associate lecturers, student reviewers and external consultants.  It could also be considered helpful in terms of professional academic development.

Critical readers are not the only people who are reviewing the materials. There are also external assessors and a number of different editors who review the module materials. There are editors who read for coherence, alignment with learning design principles, and editors who carry out copy editing, to check for typographical issues.

One note that I did make was a reflection from a module chair, who suggested that ‘you can never have too much feedback on drafts’. A reflection on this is that the quality of the feedback is also likely to important too.

Module team approaches

A bit terminology. In OU production jargon, a D2 is considered to be a first full draft. A D1 is an early draft.

Different module teams might handle critical reading in different ways. A module chair, for example, might read every block. All block authors might read each other’s block. There might be a designed critical reader for each block. Module teams might ask critical readers to focus on particular points, or to read with a certain perspective.

Discussion

We were put into breakout rooms to discuss a few questions, which I’ve taken the liberty of paraphrasing:

  • What works and what doesn’t work?
  • What sort of feedback have you found useful?
  • What information do critical readers need?
  • What are the barriers for effective practice?

I made some notes, which could be thought of as potentially helpful points and tips:

  • Time can be a barrier, which means that planning is important. It is important to integrate critical reading into a production schedule.
  • Take a multi-step approach. One critical reader may be asked to consider the big picture of a module design and provide overarching comments. Conversely, you may ask a critical reader to look at the specifics of activities (but do bear in mind that editors will pick up typos).
  • A collaborative module chair, who works across and between module team members is really helpful.
  • The qualification leads and director of teaching can play a role to ensure that programme wide learning outcomes are met, and can offer guidance about what critical readers should focus on (themes such as accessibility, employability and sustainability).

Managing conflicting feedback

When writing (and critiquing) any written work, I always try to keep in mind the perspective that we are critiquing the work, rather than the writer. This is, of course, easier said than done when we receive a lot of comments. What I would also add to the points made in this part of the session is: if you think something is especially good or useful, it is useful to say so.

Here are the points that I noted down from this section:

  • Remember that everyone has different experiences and perspectives. What they may say might well be valid, from their perspective.
  • ‘Seniority does not automatically suggest someone is right.’
  • If there is a disagreement, Is there a compromise? A resolution might also mean getting further perspectives from other readers or other team members.

Reviewing critical reading guidance

Towards the end of the session, we had a very read through of five documents; three checklists and two guidance documents. We didn’t have much time to look through these, but I will share what looked to be significant.

Science checklist

The science checklist had 12 rows, which covered useful topics such as timing, style, and learning outcomes, with a separate table that related to equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI). There was a row to leave a tick (or a cross), and space for comments.

Science prompts

Rather than a checklist, one document had a set of prompts. It began with a short introduction, and had the headings: Interest/engagement, difficulty, clarity and structure, timing, and any other comments or feedback. Under each heading there was a couple of sentences of additional guidance.

Education feedback form

This divided into 8 rows. The (abridged) heading were: content, teaching, difficulty, readings, AV material, impact on students, summary, and any other comments. Accompanying each row were a set of useful probe questions.

I’ll now turn to one that has been prepared by a module team that I have a connection with (which we didn’t discuss).

Computing feedback form

There is a separate guidance document that has the title ‘what we ask of you’, followed by a timetable, and an appendix that addresses the EDI and accessibility issues that need to be considered. Our form has 8 sections: topic ‘strategy’, content appropriateness, likes and dislikes (or, strengths and weaknesses), anything that might be missing, connection with learning outcomes, whether the materials are engaging, and EDI and accessibility points. The computing critical reading guide also suggests that the readers can return their feedback in any way that works for them.

Reflections

The first time I did some critical reading, I really felt that I wasn’t very good at it. I wasn’t sure whether the module chair wanted me to give a high level overview of everything, or wanted me to look at the specifics of individual activities.

An important point that I noted down was the need to provide suggestions that are actionable. Whilst comments such as ‘this activity needs to be further refined’ may reflect a need for some materials to be looked at again, specific comments are also useful comments. A related point is the importance of ‘module overload’. Does a module have too much, in terms of content, activities or assessment? This point links back to the role and importance of qualification directors.

Out of all the forms I looked at, I liked the education form, since it provided a set of really useful probes. In some ways, the computing forms and guidance also does this, but in a slightly different way. Putting forms to one side, what really matter is people: the writers and the readers. This links back to an earlier point about the importance of a collaborative chair.

Acknowledgements

Many thanks are given to Judith Croston who designed and facilitated this helpful session.

Permalink
Share post

This blog might contain posts that are only visible to logged-in users, or where only logged-in users can comment. If you have an account on the system, please log in for full access.

Total visits to this blog: 4627845