AI and the Catastrophic Collapse of Supply and Demand
If a service is free and unlimited, the skill behind it has no value. Unlimited supply plus no willingness to pay means no market. Firms lose their reason to exist, and each one is simultaneously supplier, customer, and, as an employer, a source of consumer demand. So the loss compounds in every direction.
New technology always closes doors and opens others. AI opens eight billion doors. But who pays you to walk through yours when everyone already has one? That isn't only true of the individual but of a company too.
Executive summary
The first economic break from AI is not mass unemployment. It is the loss of the business-to-business market, and it happens in every direction at once, because many firms will simply have no reason to exist.
Firms sell cognitive services to each other: marketing, legal, insurance, finance, HR, IT, design, sales support and data. AI lets each firm provide those services for itself at near-zero cost, so demand for the external specialist falls towards zero in every market at the same moment. The argument in brief:
- It is a mesh, not a chain. Every firm is both supplier and customer of the others. There is no first domino, and no firm is safe because its neighbours fail first.
- Each firm's saving is another firm's lost revenue. Insourcing is rational for one firm and ruinous for all of them.
- Insolvency accelerates the loop but does not start it. Demand has left every floor before any firm fails.
- Nothing balances it. Falling prices do not revive demand when the buyer's alternative is no supplier, and no sector is left to steady the rest.
- The damage then spreads outwards: the local economy empties, property and the assets behind it are impaired, the tax base disappears, and AI firms lose the customers who buy their tokens.
Taxing AI profits to fund a basic income presupposes a market that has already gone. The real question is what institutional structure replaces it.
Introduction
The standard story of AI and the economy imagines super-efficient companies, streamlined and automated, with a CEO conducting a symphony of AI agents and generating enormous profits. Few people are employed, but at least there are profits to tax for a universal basic income. That story skips the stage where the economy actually breaks.
Before we reach that end-state, supply and demand collapse. The first collapse is not consumer demand falling because of mass unemployment. That comes later. The first collapse is business-to-business demand, and it has a particular shape. It is not a chain of dominoes with a first firm and a last. It is a mesh. Every firm is both a supplier and a customer of every other firm, and AI gives every one of them the same ability to provide its own specialist services. So every firm stops buying externally at the same time. Every firm's revenue, which is only the sum of what other firms buy from it, falls together, in every direction.
This essay models that collapse using a single office block as a microcosm of the B2B economy. It follows the mesh to its end: not wealth concentrated at the top, but wealth evaporating everywhere, AI firms included.
1. The Office Block as a B2B Ecosystem
Picture a ten-storey office block. Each floor is a business selling a specialised service to other businesses:
- Floor 10 Marketing. Campaigns, copywriting, SEO, analytics, media buying.
- Floor 9 Legal and compliance. Contracts, regulatory checks, research, routine disputes.
- Floor 8 Insurance. Underwriting, claims, pricing, fraud detection.
- Floor 7 Finance and accounting. Bookkeeping, reporting, risk analysis, advisory.
- Floor 6 HR and IT. Payroll, recruitment, helpdesk, code.
- Floor 5 Design, translation and administration. Graphics, document processing, translation.
- Floor 4 Sales and customer service. Lead generation, chatbots, voice agents.
- Floor 3 Data and analytics. Market analysis, forecasting, reporting.
- Floor 2 Catering. Staff lunches, client entertaining, coffee.
- Floor 1 Cleaning and facilities. Cleaning, maintenance, security.
Outside the building there is a car dealership, a restaurant and a shopping centre.
What matters is the density of the web, not any order within it. Marketing buys legal, accounting, insurance, IT, design, data, catering and cleaning. Legal buys marketing, insurance, finance and the same list. Insurance, finance, data and every other floor do likewise. Every firm leases cars from the dealership. Staff eat at the restaurant and shop at the centre, which in turn buy marketing, legal, insurance, finance, catering and cleaning. The building owner buys cleaning, maintenance and security. Taxes flow to local government, wages flow to employees, and employees spend locally.
Nothing in the block is a pure supplier or a pure customer. Each floor's income is another floor's expenditure. That is what makes it an ecosystem, and it is what makes it fragile in one specific way: the whole circuit runs on cognitive services being bought from outside the firm.

2. AI as Unlimited Supply of Cognitive Skill
AI does not merely make each firm's service cheaper. It makes each service self-providable by the firm's own clients. Once a cognitive skill is encoded in a model or an agent, it can be copied and deployed at near-zero marginal cost. "Unlimited" does not mean literally infinite. It means supply becomes extremely elastic relative to demand, and quality becomes good enough for the great majority of routine business needs.
The critical point is that the buyer becomes its own supplier. The marketing firm's clients do not need a cheaper marketing firm; they need no marketing firm. The same is true of legal, insurance, finance, HR, IT, design, administration, sales, customer service and data.
And the capability arrives for every firm at once. There is no early adopter whose clients are lost to a rival while everyone else carries on as before. The same skill is available to every floor at the same moment, which is why the collapse has no starting point.
The demand for the function remains. The demand for the external specialist goes to zero.
3. There Is No First Domino
The natural way to tell this story is as a sequence: marketing dies, then legal, then insurance, then finance. That is the wrong shape, and it hides the point.
Take the legal firm. Its clients are the other floors, and every one of them can now draft contracts, run compliance checks and do first-pass research in-house. Its routine work disappears from every client at once. The marketing firm, the insurer and the accountants have not failed. They have simply stopped buying. Meanwhile the legal firm is itself a customer, and it is making the same decision about marketing, accounting, design and data. Its own insourcing removes revenue from each of those floors in turn.
Now repeat that for every floor. Each firm is at the same moment a seller losing every client and a buyer withdrawing from every supplier. There is no origin to the cascade, because each firm is both a cause of other firms' losses and a victim of their decisions.
This is a fallacy of composition. For any single firm, insourcing is rational: it saves money. But one firm's saving is another firm's lost revenue, so the sum of the savings across the block equals the sum of the losses. What works for one firm cannot work for all, because the revenue of one is the cost of another.
A second effect tightens the mesh. A specialist's costs are largely fixed. As clients leave, those costs are spread over fewer of them, so the price per remaining client has to rise, or quality has to fall. Either pushes the remaining clients towards insourcing, which pushes the price up again.
Firms will not fail in lockstep. Those whose work is most routine will go first, and in hindsight the order will look like dominoes. But the order reflects how quickly each firm's work is absorbed, not a causal chain between firms. Demand had already left every floor before any firm was declared insolvent.
Insolvency is a consequence, not the mechanism. When a firm goes bust it stops paying its own suppliers: retainers are cancelled, premiums stop, cars are returned, catering and cleaning contracts end, staff stop spending locally, tax payments stop. That accelerates the loop. It did not start it.

4. Zero Demand, Unlimited Supply
For each service the relevant demand curve is not demand for the function. It is demand for the external supplier. Picture a standard supply and demand chart, price on the vertical axis and quantity on the horizontal.
The supply curve shifts right towards near-horizontal at a price close to zero. AI can supply enormous quantity at very low marginal cost.
The demand curve for the external firm shifts left towards zero, because clients self-provide.
The old equilibrium moves towards the origin. At unlimited supply and zero external demand, there is no market-clearing price, and the quantity traded goes to zero.
The market does not clear at a low price. It disappears.
Some functions will persist where a human must sign, certify or be held liable. But they are the residue: too small to sustain a floor, and themselves bought by a shrinking pool of firms.

That is what is unique about this catastrophe. It is not that supply cannot meet demand. It is that supply becomes unlimited while demand for the external supplier vanishes, in every market in the block simultaneously.
5. The Feedback Loops
The mesh can be modelled as a set of causal loops. The first is the engine. The others are amplifiers.
Notice what is missing: a balancing loop. In an ordinary downturn, falling prices revive demand, and sectors that hold up keep buying from the others and steady the system. Here neither works. A price falling towards zero does not revive demand, because the buyer's alternative is not a cheaper supplier but no supplier. And no sector stabilises the block, because every sector has the same substitute.

6. The Physical Floors and the Outside Businesses
Catering and cleaning are physical services and cannot be automated in the same way. But their demand depends on occupied floors and paid staff. As the cognitive firms lose their markets, the building empties, fewer people buy lunch and fewer firms pay for cleaning. The car dealership depends on company fleets and on employees with disposable income, and both disappear. The restaurant and shopping centre depend on office footfall and local spending, and both disappear. The building owner loses tenants, rent and property value, defers maintenance, and the building becomes an empty shell.

7. Even AI Does Not Escape: Who Buys the Tokens?
AI companies are not exempt. Token demand is derived demand. Firms buy tokens to produce services they can sell, and consumers buy subscriptions with income. If firms have no customers and workers have no income, token demand falls.
AI companies can automate their own operations, but they still need energy, chips, data centres, land, water and maintenance, and they need customers. Wealthy owners can buy some tokens but not enough to sustain a mass market. Government can buy some, but its tax base is eroding. Internal AI use can absorb some, but not enough to justify the capital invested.
So who buys the tokens? In the absence of a functioning downstream economy, almost nobody. The AI firms are not the last survivors sitting on a mountain of profit. Their revenue was always derived from the economy they helped to dissolve, and they are among its last casualties.
8. Property and the Collapse of Asset Values
Empty office blocks are not assets. They are liabilities, needing maintenance, security, insurance and property tax. The owner cannot sell because there are no buyers with money. The bank holding the mortgage cannot recover value, because the collateral is impaired. The pension fund that invested in the building cannot pay out in full. Residential property follows: laid-off workers cannot pay rent or mortgages, landlords lose income, and values fall.
There is no wealth stored in property to tax, because property has no market price when nobody can buy it.

9. The Secondary Collapse: Employment, Consumers and the Trades
Only after the B2B market has gone does mass unemployment become the dominant driver of demand collapse. Layoffs reduce household income, which reduces consumer spending, which kills restaurants, shops, dealerships and hospitality, which lay off more workers.
That consumer collapse is real, but it is secondary, and the distinction matters for policy. If the problem were only wage income, redistribution could sustain demand. But if the B2B market itself has disappeared, redistribution cannot recreate the external specialist firms. They are gone because their function has been internalised.
Many displaced cognitive workers will try to retrain into physical trades. The supply of tradespeople rises sharply while demand falls, because households have less money and commercial construction has stopped. Empty offices do not need fit-outs, and empty restaurants do not need kitchen repairs. Prices and incomes fall.

Chart G Physical trades supply and demand · illustrative. Retraining does not rescue anyone. Supply of tradespeople rises just as demand for paid trades falls, so both wages and the number of paid jobs drop.
10. The Tax Base: There Is Nothing to Tax
By this stage the traditional tax base has not merely eroded. It has gone.
Payroll and income tax: employment is gone.
VAT: consumer spending is gone.
Corporate profit tax: profits are gone, because firms are bust.
Commercial property tax: the offices are empty and impaired.
Capital gains and inheritance tax: assets have no market price.
AI rents and excess profits: the AI firms are casualties too.
The fiscal options usually proposed in AI debates, such as capital taxes, wealth taxes, land value taxes, compute taxes and public equity stakes, all presuppose a functioning economy with measurable wealth and profitable firms. In the office block, that economy has been abolished by self-provision. The mountain of AI profit is a mirage.
What remains is not a redistribution problem. It is a structural absence. The physical capacity still exists, in empty buildings, idle workers and abundant compute. The institutional forms that turned capacity into market activity have collapsed.
11. Central Banks: Printing into a Void
Once the businesses are bust and assets impaired, the only remaining fiscal actor is the central bank, and its only tool is money creation. Technically it can create money electronically and fund public spending or a basic income. With abundant idle capacity, this may support some consumption without immediate inflation, at least in elastic sectors. But the constraints are serious:
Printing is a claim on output, not wealth creation. It creates nominal demand with no supply chain to meet it. It does not recreate the marketing firm, the legal firm or the restaurant.
It cannot rebuild the B2B market, because the specialist firms were abolished by internalisation.
It may cause inflation in bottlenecks such as energy, chips, housing, food and logistics.
Repeated printing erodes currency credibility and inflation expectations.
It requires political control of the central bank, which undermines independence.
Programmable digital money could direct spending, but it raises surveillance and exclusion problems. It is a tool of control, not a solution.

Printing can buy time. It cannot substitute for the organisational capacity that has collapsed.
12. The End State and the Real Question
The office block model does not end with a CEO conducting a symphony of agents and profits to tax. It ends with empty buildings, idle workers, abundant compute with no customers, impaired property, no tax base, a central bank printing into a void, and a population with no wages, no assets and no consumer power. The physical capacity for abundance exists. The organisational capacity to deliver it has collapsed.
So the real question is not how to tax the AI profits. It is what institutional structure replaces the market when the market abolishes itself. The possible answers are none of them easy:
- Public provision of goods and services using idle capacity and AI tools, financed by money creation and rationing rather than taxes on nonexistent profits.
- Worker and community ownership of the means of production, including compute and infrastructure, organised outside the market.
- A planned or hybrid allocation system for essential goods, using AI for logistics and matching, under democratic control.
- A subsistence economy in which people produce for themselves and their communities, with AI as a tool rather than a market.
- Collapse: lower living standards, decayed infrastructure and reduced population until a new equilibrium emerges.
None of these is "tax the AI profits and fund a basic income". That option needs a functioning market with profitable firms and taxable wealth.
Conclusion
The office block does not collapse floor by floor. It collapses everywhere at once, because every firm is every other firm's customer, and AI has given every firm the means to stop buying. Each firm's decision to insource is individually rational and collectively ruinous. Demand for the external specialist goes to zero in every market in the block simultaneously, insolvency accelerates the loop, and there is no balancing force to stop it, because every sector shares the same substitute.
The tax base follows, then property, then the banks and pension funds that held it, then local government, then the AI firms whose customers have gone. The only remaining actor is the central bank, and what it can do is a holding action.
The economy does not concentrate wealth at the top. It evaporates wealth everywhere. The office block is empty, and the question is not who taxes the profits. It is what comes after the market has abolished itself.
The Office Block: AI and the Catastrophic Collapse of Supply and Demand — Russell Larke.