OU blog

Personal Blogs

Locke stocke and barrele

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Terry O'Sullivan, Friday 7 October 2011 at 10:35

Had brain trouble trying to get to grips with the Locke reading. I think the reason is that I'm coming to it with my own convictions about the nature of the self (i.e. indivisible from what I believe is the soul, responsible, continuous from conception to death, learning, future-oriented, etc.) so have to get round them to give him room for his. Is this bracketing of my own convictions part of what philosophers call charity?

I also find myself uncomfortable with the term 'thought experiment' which seems an important one in the apparatus of philosophy. Why not call them 'scenarios' or 'hypothetical situations' instead? The term 'experiment' just seems misleading to me, for the reasons mentioned in the course materials (ie. associated with a process of isolating a variable and studying its behaviour in relation to one or more other variables in a controlled situation). The term just sounds fatuous and nerdy to me. I wonder why I feel so strongly about this?

With Locke I just feel like shaking the bloke and saying -- but you can't have two minds in one body!, Socrates' soul has not transferred to the Mayor of whereever it is (whoever he was!), what is all that about a little finger for god's sake, and the prince and cobbler proves nothing because it's just a daft storyangry. I can only imagine I have misunderstood all this stuff and after I have lain down in a darkened room for a bit, all will become clear.

The final bit about the law justly punishing drunks and sleepwalkers because they can't prove they can't remember their amnesia also seems daft. You can't prove you've forgotten something in any case, so why does Locke excuse amnesiacs from responsibility earlier in the extract (as I understand it at the moment anyway)? God setting all things right at the day of judgement sounds like a nice back stop, but we should not have to wait that long to be just (I'm sure God agrees) and if you follow that argument (i.e. it will all come out in the divine wash) to its ultimate conclusion you might end up abandoning the project of human justice altogether.

Permalink 1 comment (latest comment by Tony Kelly, Friday 7 October 2011 at 16:09)
Share post

This blog might contain posts that are only visible to logged-in users, or where only logged-in users can comment. If you have an account on the system, please log in for full access.

Total visits to this blog: 26975