OU blog

Personal Blogs

Richard Walker

The Joy of Antiproverbs

Visible to anyone in the world

Wiktionary defines an antiproverb as: " A humorous adaptation of one or more existing proverbs."

There are many forms but a common one starts with one proverb, then switches in midstream to another. For example, the daftly incongruous

"Every dog has a silver lining"

Or the sardonic

"No news is the mother of invention."

Here are more examples from [1]

Don’t count your chickens in midstream
You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t have it both ways.
Too many cooks are better than one.
An apple a day is worth two in the bush.

The word antiproverb was coined by Wolfgang Mieder and there is quite a literature about antiproverbs [2][3]. People who study proverbs are paremiologists, a word new to me but paremiology is in the OED and attested from 1861, derived from Latin paroemia, Greek παροιμία.

I thought I would try to generate some antiproverbs of my own, so I got a list of just under 1,000 proverbs and generated many random pairs, looking for good combinations. It turned out harder than I was expecting, but here are some that I feel show definite promise

An apple a day is better than no bread.
Don't count your chickens while the sun shines.
Many a true word is sauce for the gander.
Don’t change horses till the fat lady sings.
It’s an ill wind that never boils.
It’s easy to be wise after a free lunch.

[1]  https://wordsbybob.wordpress.com/2014/01/20/antiproverbs-say-what/

[2] https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.2478/9783110410167.15/html

[3] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/370487535_ENGLISH_ANTI-PROVERBS_AS_STYLISTIC_DEVICES

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Greedy Algorithm is Genius!

Visible to anyone in the world

I saw an "If you can solve this you are a genius" puzzle on you YouTube and it goes like this.

"You are given 49 cards numbered 1, 2, 3,..., 49 and the challenge is to put them (not necessarily equally sized) groups so that the sum of the numbers in each group is the same."

The numbers 1 to 50 add up to 1225 and 1225 divided by 7 is 175, so the cards in each group must total 175.

I've seen similar problems before and they are interesting because we can tackle them using a so-called "Greedy algorithm", which roughly speaking works by always grabbing the largest available numbers. There are many situations where a greedy algorithm doesn't work but I believe it always succeeds with the type of problem we are considering here (although I have not been able to prove this is the case.)

It's possible to come up with a computer program to carry out the algorithm but I thought it more interesting to do it manually in a spreadsheet, which shows visually how the algorithm unfolds. Here it is, it's 49 rows long of course but I've done my best to fit it in. My explanation is at the end of the post.

sketch.png 

You can see that at each step we gobble up the largest numbers unused at that point until the next largest number wiuld take up past 175. Then we choose the number or numbers that makes the total of the current group up to 175. I have coloured the groups: yellow, blue, green, pink, purple, grey and white. I think I've got the calculations right, I've checked them but it's. a bit fiddly and easy to make a mistake.

I don't for a second suggest this solution is unique, it is just what the greedy algorithm finds, but I expect there will be hundreds or thousands of other ways to solve the puzzle. I think it is probably hard to calculate how many. A simpler question is: how many subsets of 1, 2, 3,..., 49 have a total of 175 and Copilot says 63,019,177 but this is not easy to check.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

One that Euclid missed?

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Tuesday 9 September 2025 at 00:16

More than 2,000 years ago Euclid proved that in any triangle the three lines bisecting the angles of a triangle meet at a point which is the centre of the circle that touches the triangle's sides.

sketch.png

He further proved that the three lines that bisect the triangle's sides at right angles is the centre of a circle passing through the triangles three corners.

sketch%20%281%29.png

These circles, called the incircle (centre incentre) and circumcircle (centre circumcentre) still studied in schools today, for example here is quite a nice animation showing the construction of the circumcircle, from a GCSE revision site.

And if you are interested in Euclid's original proofs here you can see the relevant pages from the oldest know complete copy of Euclid's Elements, with a transcription into a readable form and an English translation. You want Book IV, Elem. 4.4 and 4.5. This website is an astonishing work of scholarship.

All that was just the preamble. Here is a neat fact I stumbled across about a week ago, when I was just doodling triangles. It's nice because it connects the angle bisectors and the perpendicular bisectors.

In a triangle the line bisecting an angle meets the perpendicular bisector of the opposite side at a point (M in the diagram below) that lies on the circumcircle

sketch%20%282%29.png

This was new to me but I thought there ought to be quite a simple and accessible proof. But after a bit of head scratching, I couldn't see one, so I thought it must be a standard result, and looked it up. I did find a few proofs, but they were all more complicated than I was hoping (and at least one was wrong). The problem is discussed on Mathematics Stack Exchange but I still didn't find the "obvious" proof I was looking for.

After days of head-scratching I finally had my eureka moment! The proof I was seeking uses the following fact.

In a given circle, any two chords with the same length subtend (i.e.make) equal angles on the circumference. Here's an example:

sketch%20%284%29.png

Now it's easy. Add some chords.

sketch%20%285%29.png

I claim that the line BM that joins B and the point M where the perpendicular bisector of AC meets the circumcircle is the line bisecting angle ABC.

Proof: Any point on the perpendicular bisector of AC is equidistant from A and C. So AM and MC are equal chords, and the angles ABM and MBC they subtend are equal, in other words BM bisects angle ABC.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Animal-ine words

Visible to anyone in the world

I was thinking about pets and that put me in mind of canine ('like or pertaining to dogs') and feline ('like or purrtaining to cats' [1]). There are many other similar words, sometime called animal-ine words, for example:

bovine - cow
equine - horse
leonine - lion
ovine - sheep
porcine - pig

Here are 16 unusual ones, all found in the OED. What animals do they refer to? How many can you guess? (Answers in comments)

anatine 
caprine 
cervine 
corvive 
leporine 
lumbricine 
lupine 
murine 
oscine 
pardine
pavonine 
phocine 
psittacine 
soricine 
ursine 
vulpine 

PS the suffix -ine comes directly from the Latin -inus which means more or less what -ine does; we can add it to noun X to get an adjective meaning X-like. 

[1] Sorry, couldn't resist it.

Permalink 1 comment (latest comment by Richard Walker, Sunday 7 September 2025 at 19:47)
Share post
Richard Walker

This Problem Is Not Impossible

Visible to anyone in the world

I saw this problem on the "Mind Your Decisions" YouTube channel and here are my two solutions, I haven't watched the video/

The Problem

sketch.png

In my sketch we have a rectangle of unknown dimensions, a quarter-circle inscribed in the rectangle, a semicircle positioned as shown with its centre on bottom of the rectangle, and a line of length 5 drawn from the corner of the rectangle and tangent to the semicircle. The challenge is to find the area of the rectangle.

At first sight this is impossible, we only have one distance so how can we find the area? 

First Solution

When a problem involves a tangent to a circle or part of one, it almost always uses the fact the a tangent makes a 90 degree angle with the radius at the point of contact; and when a problem involves a right-angled triangle and we are interested in distances, that points to Pythagoras' Theorem.

So here's the diagram again: I have labelled some key points, called the radii of the quarter and semicircle r1 and r2 respectively, drawn in the radius to point of contact D, and marked the right angle.

sketch%20%281%29.png

Now we see we have a right-angles triangle with hypotenuse r1 + r2 and its other sides 5 and r2. We can apply Pythagoras and then use some algebra on the resulting equation as follows.

sketch%20%283%29.png

But r1 and r1 + r2 are precisely the height and length of the rectangle and their product is the area of the rectangle, which must therefore be 25. r1 and r2 can take different values as long as the satisfy the relationship we ended up with above and the area must always be 25.

Second solution

We are not told the values of r1 and r2, so it must not matter as such and we are free to choose them as we like as long as our choice is compatible with the given geometry.

Very well: let's set r2 = 0. Now the semicircle collapses to a point at B, the rectangle becomes a square, and the tangent degenerates into the line AB, r2 becomes 5 and the area is (r2)2 = 25.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Black Squirrels

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Saturday 6 September 2025 at 15:23

Here is a photograph my brother took of a black squirrel.

sketch%20%286%29.png

And here are a pair of juvenile squirrels.

sketch%20%285%29.png

These are from the same litter but you can see one is jet black but the other grey with some sandy bits. I don't know whether this is just colour variation, which was my first thought, or if they have different fathers .which apparently does happen.

These black squirrels are the same species as grey squirrels but just have different colour fur. The grey squirrel is native to the Eastern US and black squirrels are fairly numerous there. At one time I thought the black squirrels in the UK were a local mutation but the current theory is that they are descended from one or more black squirrels that were released, or escaped, from a private collection in the early years of the 20th century.

They are now common in Bedfordshire, Hertfordshire and Cambridgeshire - I've often seen them - and their spread is being studied by Anglia Ruskin University. The spread is slow; although there are estimated to be about 35,000 of them they have seemingly only travelled at about 0.5 of a mile per year since their introduction, which seems quite slow.

Studies point to black grey squirrels having come about from interspecies breeding with American fox squirrels, which occupy a roughly similar geographical range to the greys and which can be several different colours, including black.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Why Are Dogs Called Dogs?

Visible to anyone in the world

It's a bit of a mystery.

In most of the languages of Europe the word for dog comes from an ancient PIE root which was something like kwon- and which appears in e.g. Latin canis, Ancient Greek kyon and Welsh corgi. In Germanic languages the k sound became h, so we get Modern German Hund and Old English hund (another example of this consonant shift is Greek kardia versus English heart, German Hertz).

For today 'hound' is reserved for dogs (or people) that hunt or track something bloodhound, newshound, or breeds of hunting dogs wolfhound, or used metaphorically, or perhaps in a jokey way. At some point in late Old English a word docga (possibly referring to a spacial breed of strong or powerful animal) emerged from completely unknown origins. During the Middle English period dog displaced hound as the standard word for members of the genus Canis and the meaning of hound narrowed to the more restricted sense it is used in today.

To me hound has more portentous feel than dog: "The Dog of the Baskervilles" wouldn't really worked.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Tom Swifty

Visible to anyone in the world

"Someone's cut off all my hair". Tom sounded distressed.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Meet the Anadromes

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Wednesday 3 September 2025 at 00:15

A palindrome is of course a word (e.g. tattarrattat, a knock at the door) or phrase (e.g. Norma is as selfless as I am Ron, my favourite) that reads the same forwards and backwards,.

But have you heard of the anadrome? An anadrome is a word the taken backwards gives a different, but perfectly good, word. The longest example in English is, as far as anyone knows, the 8-letter stressed and desserts.

I wrote a short program that searched a public-domain word list and found several 7-letter anadromes:

dessert
reviver
reifier
stinker
stellas
deifier
deified
deliver
reviled
rewarder
halalah
reified
sallets
reknits
stressed
sememes
redrawer
tressed

I rather like stinker and reknits.

If we consider shorter words there are many more anadromes: I found 397 of 2 or more letters in a list of 113809 words.

There are also some that have been made up: the unit of electrical resistance is the ohm and as far back as 1888 someone coined mho as a unit for the reciprocal of resistance, conductance. It's probably not official but I think it's quite common, I was certainly familiar with it. Another nice example I found on Wikipedia is tink, which means unknit (geddit?). This goes rather nicely with stinker and reknits, I feel.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Daffynition [1]

Visible to anyone in the world

integrate: Expression of admiration for male person

[1] See here for the definition of daffynition

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Slicing a Prism - Olympiad Problem

Visible to anyone in the world

Suppose we have a long piece of wood with a uniform cross-section which is an irregular triangle (Fig. 1), so a straight cut at right angles to the length of the timber results in a triangle all of whose sides are different.

sketch.png

Show that it is always possible to make an oblique cut at an angle in such a way that the section obtained is an equilateral triangle (Fig. 2).

This comes from the Turkish Maths Olympiad 2000 and I read about it here, p. 141. 

An outline proof appears in the comments.

Permalink 1 comment (latest comment by Richard Walker, Sunday 31 August 2025 at 00:05)
Share post
Richard Walker

The River Lea (Early Morning)

Visible to anyone in the world

sketch%20%281%29.png

The River Lea at 7 am today.

The Lea rises somewhere north of Luton and eventually flows into the Thames at London. It gives its name to Luton, which means "Settlement on the Lea". The name Lea is thought to be Celtic, like a number of English river names, and mean something like "Bright" or "Shining".

I think it is from the same Indo-European root as "light", which seems to be cognate with Latin lux "light", Greek lefkos "white", German licht, Gaelic solas "light" (in the physical sense), Welsh lleuad "moon".

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

This Simple Plant Can Ward Off Elves

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Sunday 24 August 2025 at 22:08

sketch.png

This plant, which growing profusely in my street, is Red Valerian, Valeriana Rubra (or Centranthus ruber). Originally from the Mediterranean, it has been introduced into many other parts of the globe and become widely naturalised.

The genus Valeriana was named by Linnaeus, after the Roman Emperor Valerian. Valerian means "Worthy or "Strong" and descends from the same root as "Value", "Valid", Valour" etc. Linnaeus chose this name because another Valerian species, Valeriana officinalis has been used since the time of Hippocrates as a herbal remedy with a range of uses, so I suppose he felt it deserved the description of "Worthy".

Two interesting facts about V. officinalis.

  1. It's attractive to cats, like catnip.

2. An old Swedish country superstition was that (it is so fascinating I shall quote it in full)

'… a bridegroom stands in dread of the envy of the Elves, to counteract which it has long been a custom to lay in the clothes on the wedding day certain strong-smelling plants, as garlic or valerian. Near gates and in crossways there is supposed to be the greatest danger. If any one asks a bridegroom the reason of these precautions, he will answer : " On account of envy." And there is no one so miserable whose bride will not think herself envied on her wedding day, if by no others, at least by the Elves.'

The elves would spirit the groom away

' The bride sits ready in her bridal bower, in anxious ex pectation and surrounded by her bridesmaids. The bride groom saddles his grey steed, and clad in knightly attire, with his hawk perched proudly on his shoulder, he rides forth from his mother s hall, to fetch home his bride. But in the wood where he is wont to hunt with hawk and hound, an elfin maiden has noticed the comely youth, and is now on the watch for an opportunity, though for ever so short a time, to clasp him to her breast in the flowery grove; or, at least, to the sweet tones of their stringed instruments, lightly to float along with him, hand in hand, on the verdant field. As he draws near to the elf-mount, or is about to ride through the gateway of the castle, his ears are ravished with most wondrous music, and from among the fairest maidens that he there sees dancing in a ring, the Elf-king s daughter herself steps forth fairer than them all, as it is said in the lay :
The damsel held forth her snow-white hand : " Come join in the merry dance with me."
If the knight allows himself to be charmed, and touches the fascinating hand, he is conducted to Elfland, where in halls indescribably beautiful, and gardens such as he had never beheld, he wanders about, on his Elf-bride s arm, amid lilies and roses. If at length the remembrance of his mourning betrothed enters his mind, and the Elves, who do not deliberately desire evil to mankind, are moved'

From 

Northern mythology : comprising the principal popular traditions and superstitions of Scandinavia, North Germany, and The Netherlands, volume 2  

SCANDINAVIAN POPULAR TRADITIONS AND SUPERSTITIONS (1851), VOL: 2, OF ELVES, p. 62 https://www.artandpopularculture.com/Northern_mythology_:_comprising_the_principal_popular_traditions_and_superstitions_of_Scandinavia,_North_Germany,_and_The_Netherlands,_volume_2

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Knobbly Monsters 🐊

Visible to anyone in the world

A Knobbly Monster is a journalistic device, a kind of convoluted paraphrase used because the writer felt using the same word twice running is bad style.

The example Knobbly Monsters are named after was (allegedly†) in a piece about a crocodile (or perhaps an alligator, it seems unclear) in which writer having used up "crocodile" and "large reptile" and a few other near synonyms finally, in desperation, wrote "knobby monster". 

BBC Home collected some fine examples [1]. Here's a few of my favourites; can you work out what they refer to? Answers at end.

sketch%20%282%29.png

There's also a good Guardian article [2] discussing POVs (Popular Orange Vegetables, the plant equivalents of Knobbly Monsters), which points out that most of the time it's better to use a pronoun. For instance, instead of

"Yesterday's rush hour witnessed a dragon hovering over Trafalgar Square. The fearsome fire-breathing scaly beast first appeared at about 8 am..."

we should write

"Yesterday's rush hour witnessed a dragon hovering over Trafalgar Square. It first appeared at about 8 am..."

† PS did you know someone who alleges something can be called an allegator?

Answers to quiz

sketch%20%283%29.png

References

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/lancashire/fun_stuff/2004/09/07/monsters.shtml

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/media/mind-your-language/2010/jun/02/my-synonym-hell-mind-your-language?guni=Article:in%20body%20link

My thanks also go to the popular YouTube channel Words Unravelled, which first introduced me to the joy of Knobbly Monsters.

Permalink 1 comment (latest comment by Richard Walker, Friday 22 August 2025 at 16:31)
Share post
Richard Walker

Where Did "Goed" Go?

Visible to anyone in the world

For some reason I wondered about the origins of "go" and when I looked it up found a discussion of why the past tense of "go" is "went" rather than "goed". It is rather strange.

In Old English "go" was gan, the ancestor of the modern word, and it already had an irregular plural eode, a word of unknown origin.

At that time "went" was the past of wendan, connected with modern wind (as in turn). "Wend" has survived into Modern English as "wend", as in wend ones way. Nowadays the word has narrowed its meaning to imply travelling in a circuitous and roundabout way and has a rather archaic ring, but originally seems to have meant wind in the general sense.

"Wend" had a past tense "went" (like spend -> spent; send -> sent; lend -> lent; rend (meaning rip) -> rent and probably others) and for some reason is Early Middle English this started to be used in place of eode, which was eventually replaced, and disappeared from the language.

But why was "goed" not adopted? One possibility could be to avoid confusion with "good" which would at that point have had a vowel sound like that in "oak" and a 'g' like that in "go". Just a theory, I don't really have a grasp on these sound changes.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Quinquisecting an equilateral triangle

Visible to anyone in the world

It is possible to dissect an equilateral into 2, 3, 4 and 6 congruent parts, as seen in the sketches below.

sketch%20%281%29.png

But what about 5 parts? This seems more tricky, if only because it is hard to find a 5-fold symmetry associated with an equilateral triangle, and although I don't know of a proof, I think it is probably impossible - at least if we demand that each piece be a connected shape.

However, if we sacrifice this requirement and allow detached parts, a "quinquisection" then becomes possible. Here is a highly ingenious solution found by Mikhail A. Patrakeev, whose paper can be found here.

sketch%20%283%29.png

This remarkable construction uses a sort of hybrid symmetry, exploiting three fundamental isometries (transformations that preserve lengths and angles): reflection, translation and rotation.

Firstly Pink and Blue are congruent because they are refections of one another in the line down the middle of the triangle. So they are congruent.

sketch%20%284%29.png

Secondly, Green is a translation of Blue, a shift up and right at an angle of 60 degrees. So Green is congruent to Blue (and hence to Pink).

sketch%20%285%29.png

Lastly, Yellow and Orange are rotations of Green by 120 and 240 degrees, so they are congruent to it and hence to Blue and Pink as well.

sketch%20%286%29.png

And therefore all five sets are congruent as claimed. A very pretty and clever solution.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Elementary my dear WAtSON

Visible to anyone in the world

As a wordplay enthusiast I've often mused over what words can be formed by combining the symbols of the chemical elements.

For example, Actinium-Actinium-Iodine-Arsenic would give "acacias" and Barium-Oxygen-Barium-Boron-Sulphur would give "Baobabs".

A while ago I did try to come up with some  examples by hand but only found a few, so I decided to write a little program in Python.(see below[*]). For simplicity I just used lowercase letters e.g. "h", "he", "li" etc. but putting back the capitals would not be too hard. I also excluded the artificial transuranic elements (26 found to date) but again adding them would be easy enough. My reason for omitting them is that their name and symbols are a bit less familiar.

Also note it uses a "greedy" algorithm and if the first two letters is a valid symbol it chooses that first, so it can't handle "those", because it finds "th" (Thorium), then "os" (Osmium), and now the "e' is orphaned. To overcome this I'd need to add some backtracking capability so the program gets a bit more complex.

I analysed an open-source word list of 113,810 words and found 13,435 - let's call them "elementary" - words, about 12%. We'd expect the chances of a word being elementary to fall off as words gets longer, because only 92 one- or two-letter combinations of letters are symbols of chemical elements but the total number of possible one- or two-letter combination is 702, so only about 1 in 8 correspond to elements.

Nonetheless I found some surprisingly examples, with the champion being the 16-letter "counteraccusations". Here are some other long ones.

acacias
acarpous
accepters
accessions
accountancy
accurateness
accuratenesses
articulatenesses
counteraccusation

"counteraccusations" represents Cobalt Uranium Nitrogen Tellurium Radium Carbon Copper (Cu) Samarium Titanium Oxygen Nitrogen Sulphur; 11 distinct elements which I imagine is a record.

What about whole sentences? It's not easy to make up natural-sounding ones, but here is my attempt at one from a scientific setting. I've added proper punctuation to make it more realistic.

"Pop both new boxes in lab one Gabby, ta."

[*] Program follows: list of symbols, then function to test words  then sample function calls.

elements = [
    "h", "he", "li", "be", "b", "c", "n", "o", "f", "ne",
    "na", "mg", "al", "si", "p", "s", "cl", "ar", "k", "ca",
    "sc", "ti", "v", "cr", "mn", "fe", "co", "ni", "cu", "zn",
    "ga", "ge", "as", "se", "br", "kr", "rb", "sr", "y", "zr",
    "nb", "mo", "tc", "ru", "rh", "pd", "ag", "cd", "in", "sn",
    "sb", "te", "i", "xe", "cs", "ba", "la", "ce", "pr", "nd",
    "pm", "sm", "eu", "gd", "tb", "dy", "ho", "er", "tm", "yb",
    "lu", "hf", "ta", "w", "re", "os", "ir", "pt", "au", "hg",
    "tl", "pb", "bi", "po", "at", "rn", "fr", "ra", "ac", "th",
    "pa", "u"
]

def parse(word):

    result = []

    while len(word) > 0:

        token1 = word[0:1]
        token2 = word[0:2]

        # Look for two-letter symbol first
        if token2 in elements:
            result.append(token2)
            word = word[2:]

        # If not check for 1--letter symbol 
        elif token1 in elements:
            result.append(token1)
            word = word[1:]

        else:
            return 'fail'
        
    return result

print(parse('cream'))
print(parse('scone'))
Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Solution to Geometry Question 13 August

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Thursday 14 August 2025 at 14:08

See question here.

sketch%20%282%29.png

Consider the triangles ACD and BCE.

In these triangles AC = BC because ABC is equilateral and CD = CE because CDE is equilateral.

Angle ACD = angle BCE because both are α plus 60°.

So ACD and BCE have two pairs of equal sides and an equal included angle, which means they are congruent  and consequently AD = BE.

Not only are they equal, but they intersect at 60°. Can you give a proof?

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

A Geometry Question

Visible to anyone in the world

Equilateral triangles ABC and CDE share a common vertex at C. Prove that AD and BE are equal in length.

sketch%20%282%29.png

Solution tomorrow.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Black and white and red all over?

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Saturday 9 August 2025 at 18:50

Yesterday for some reason I thought of the word "redden" - go red or make redder - which set me to wondering if there are similar words involving other colours. "Blacken and whiten" came readily to mind but when I thought about "bluen" for example it didn't feel right, I wasn't sure there was such a word.

So I searched, using the 11 basic English colour names, first in the OED and then if a word was not there, in Wiktionary, and turned up several more. 

Redden OED
Blacken OED
Whiten OED
Greenen not found
Yellowen Wiktionary
Bluen Wiktionary
Brownen not found
Pinken OED
Greyen Wiktionary
Purplen not found
Orangen not found

There is a large literature that deals with the order in which colour names might have evolved and I wondered at first if the colours with and without -en compounds might reflect that in some way. Then a different explanation occurred to me. Here from ResearchGate is a chart of the frequencies with which the colour names are found, taken from Google n-grams. [1]

sketch%20%281%29.png

Apart from the rather surprising "pinken" there seems to be a clear pattern. The words I thought of first correspond to the commonest terms; the others I found corresponded to the moderately common terms, except green and brown, presumably because "greenen" and "brownen" are awkward words to say*; and the rarer words don't have an -en compound.

This raises an intriguing possibility; if we come across a few odd fragments of writing from the ancient civilisation of Fantasia and were by some miracle able to identify and translate a handful colour words, the chances of the terms for red, black and white occurring would be high, while orange, pink and purple would be unlikely. We might conclude, quite erroneously, that the ancient Fantasians had no word for purple, or even that they couldn't distinguish purple from blue.

* In contract to -en compounds we can add -ish to any colour we like and come up with a word that feels perfectly reasonable, for example turquoiseish or heliotopeish.

[1] https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Frequencies-of-the-11-basic-color-terms-in-English-case-insensitive-from-the-Google_fig4_332699088

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

Figure-Tracing Puzzles

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Thursday 7 August 2025 at 23:17

Every now and again someone comes up to me in a pub or a hotel or a classroom and sketches this little picture.

sketch%20%281%29.png"Can you draw this", they say, "without going over the same bit twice or lifting the pen off the paper?"

"I can", I say, and then I try to explain how I can be so confident without even picking up the pen. Here's how it goes.

First identify each point where two of more lines meet.sketch%20%282%29.png

Now count how many lines meet at each point. sketch%20%284%29.png

For it to be possible to trace the figure it's necessary that either:

  • All the numbers are even, or;
  • Two and only are odd (as is the case here) and you start from one of these and end at the other. 

This is because every time you pass through a point you add 2 to the count. If you start and finish at the same point then an extra 1 is added when start and another 1 again when you finish, so all the counts are even. Otherwise if we start and finish at different points, both get an extra 1, so their final count will be odd but all the other counts even.

Providing one of these holds it can be proved (but I'm not going do so here, it's not that hard but a bit too long) that the figure can be traced. And here's a solution (not the only one). The points with an odd count are highlighted.

sketch%20%285%29.png

These ideas were first articulated by Leonhard Euler in 1736. A problem that must have been going the rounds at the time concerned the seven bridges of Königsberg (in Prussia then; now Kaliningrad in Russia). The puzzle was: is it possible to find a tour that crossed each bridge exactly once.

Here are the bridges as shown in Euler's original paper, which you can find in translation here.

sketch%20%287%29.png

Out of interest I looked for the bridges on Google Earth and as you can see only five are still there; b and d were presumably destroyed in WW II. I hope I have identified the other five correctly.

sketch%20%288%29.png

Now if we take A, B , C and D to be points, and the original seven bridges a - g as lines connecting the points, we get this figure, and the problem of the Königsberg bridges becomes one of tracing the figure without crossing any bridge twice or taking the pen off the paper.

sketch%20%289%29.png

All four of A - D have an odd number of lines meeting at them, so from the discussion given earlier the puzzle of the seven bridges has no solution, although with only the five bridges that have survived it does become possible to make a tour of the desired kind, starting at A and ending at D, or vice versa.

Euler called his paper, which has since become very famous, "SOLUTION OF A PROBLEM IN THE GEOMETRY OF POSITION" and it gave rise to the branch of mathematics now called graph theory: nothing to do with x and y-axes, or plotting lines and parabolas etc., but concerned with the properties of arrangements consisting of points (vertices) connected by lines (edges). As well as being of great intrinsic interest and beauty, graph theory is a vital tool in the design of the algorithms and data structures behind the computer programs that play such an important role in modern life.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

A Bathroom Etymology

Visible to anyone in the world

Sponge: A long pedigree. From Old English sponge, from Latin spongia, from Greek σπογγιά "spongia", and (speculatively) from a distant non-IE origin. 

Loofah: Easy one. A 19c borrowing from Arabic lufah = loofah plant

Soap: From Old English sape = soap but (excitingly) may at one time have meant a red hair dye German warriors wore to look fearsome*. The meaning of soap as we know it has cognates in other Germanic languages, e.g. Modern German Seife = soap. 

Flannel: Uncertain; possibly from Welsh gwlan wool, from Old Celtic *wlana = wool.

Towel: From Old French toaille with a similar meaning, from a Germanic root, and with borrowing into several Romance languages and cognates in Old High German, Dutch and Old English, with meanings to do with washing, wiping, drying etc.

Sources: OED, Etymonline

* Or maybe not. Red hair is mentioned in Roman sources but modern commentators have suggested that this was just the red hair often found amongst people of Celtic and Germanic descent. According to the BBC about as many as 13% of people in present-day Scotland may have red hair for example.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

A Mondegreen in the wild

Visible to anyone in the world

My friend heard a song by Duffy and when she sang

sketch%20%281%29.png

what he heard was

sketch%20%282%29.png

"Mercy" makes better sense, people don't often beg for birdseed, but that's not necessarily how Mondegreens work.  In The Language Instinct Steve Pinker mentions Mondegreens and notes that the mishearing is often fits the context less well than the original word and this seems be an example of that.

Yet perhaps a singer begging for birdseed does have some kind of underlying logic, when you think about it.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

A landscape at Wimpole

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Sunday 3 August 2025 at 19:41

sketch%20%284%29.png                         A view of parkland at Wimpole Hall, with the Folly in the distance.

Permalink
Share post
Richard Walker

How Many Polyhedra?

Visible to anyone in the world
Edited by Richard Walker, Saturday 2 August 2025 at 13:42

"AI Overview" in Chrome says a polyhedron is:

"a three-dimensional geometric shape with flat polygonal faces, straight edges, and sharp corners or vertices"

which is not a bad definition in my view. Some of these polyhedra are familiar to us; for example here is a back-of-an-envelope sketch of some with 4, 5 and 6 faces.sketch%20%281%29.png

Note that we are not concerned here with the particular angles or side lengths, just with the topology: how many faces and vertices there are, how many sides each face has, and what faces fit with what other faces around each vertex. 

The solid with 4 faces - a tetrahedron aka triangular pyramid - is the only possibility for 4 faces, and for 5 faces there are exactly two polyhedra - the pyramid with a quadrilateral base and the triangular prism.

The two hexahedra shown are not the only ones however. There are 7 altogether; can you find some or all of the remaining ones? Solution in the Comments.

As the number of faces grows the number of possible polyhedra climbs exponentially [1].

4 1
5 2
6 7
7 34
8 257
9 2606
10 32300
11 4.4E+05
12 6.4E+06
13 9.6E+07
14 1.5E+09
15 2.4E+10
16 3.9E+11
17 6.4E+12
18 1.1E+14

Numbers up 10 faces are exact, but those from 11 on are only estimated.

Amazingly Steven Dutch has enumerated and classified all 2606 enneahedra, finishing on 2 November 2016 [2].

Here's a quick question to finish - what is a regular hexahedron better known as?

References

[1] https://oeis.org/search?q=A000944&language=english&go=Search

[2] https://stevedutch.net/symmetry/polynum0.htm

Permalink 1 comment (latest comment by Richard Walker, Friday 1 August 2025 at 21:58)
Share post

This blog might contain posts that are only visible to logged-in users, or where only logged-in users can comment. If you have an account on the system, please log in for full access.

Total visits to this blog: 3203845